In Mani v. The Inspector of Police (Crl.A(MD) No. 27 of 2017, decided 19 November 2026), Justice D. Lingeswaran of the Madras High Court, Madurai Bench, decided an appeal against a 2016 POCSO conviction in which the defence had cross-examined only one of fifteen prosecution witnesses. The judgment answers a question that recurs in appellate practice: can the appellate court remand a case so the defence can cross-examine witnesses it chose not to challenge at trial?
The prosecution case
The appellant, aged 37 and the survivor's uncle by marriage, was alleged to have taken the 17-year-old from her village in Thanjavur district on 16 September 2014, kept her in hotel rooms in Chennai and Tiruppur, and committed repeated penetrative sexual assault before leaving her back at her village on 25 September 2014, when the FIR was lodged. The trial court (Fast Track Mahila Court, Thanjavur) convicted him in December 2016 under Sections 365 and 366 IPC and Section 6 of the POCSO Act, sentencing him to seven, ten and ten years respectively, concurrent.
The trial had one extraordinary feature: of fifteen prosecution witnesses, the defence cross-examined only the doctor (PW9). The survivor, her parents, her aunt and the investigating officers all went unchallenged.
The remand plea — and why it failed
On appeal, the defence sought a remand to cross-examine the uncross-examined witnesses. The Court refused, for three stacked reasons:
Conviction, counts and sentence
On the merits, the survivor's testimony — effectively unchallenged — was corroborated by the medical evidence (hymen not intact) and by her parents and aunt. Her age made consent immaterial, and the Court found the appellant's own account as DW1 not credible. The Section 6 POCSO conviction (through Section 5(l) — repeated assault) and the Section 366 IPC conviction stood.
The Court nevertheless corrected two trial-court errors. The Section 365 IPC conviction was set aside because it rested on the same act of abduction as Section 366 — one act cannot sustain two overlapping convictions. And the Section 366 sentence was reduced from ten years to three years rigorous imprisonment, the Court noting that the child was induced by a job pretext rather than seized by force. The ten-year POCSO sentence — the minimum under Section 6 as it stood before the 2019 amendment — remained, with concurrency and set-off under Section 428 CrPC.
| Count | Trial court | High Court |
|---|---|---|
| Section 365 IPC | 7 years RI | Conviction set aside; fine refundable |
| Section 366 IPC | 10 years RI | Upheld; sentence reduced to 3 years RI |
| Section 6 POCSO | 10 years RI | Upheld in full (statutory minimum pre-2019) |
Lessons for the defence and the prosecution
For defence counsel, the case is a stark warning: cross-examination rights must be exercised at trial, and a recall application refused and affirmed is the end of the road. Appellate courts will scrutinise the record for prejudice, but they will not reward strategic silence with a retrial — least of all in POCSO cases, where Section 33(5) weighs against recalling the child. For the prosecution, the judgment shows that investigative lapses (the hotels were never traced) are not fatal where the survivor's account is consistent and corroborated. And for sentencing practice, it is a clean illustration of appellate courts enforcing the rule against double-counting overlapping IPC offences while respecting statutory minimums under special legislation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an appellate court order a retrial so the defence can cross-examine witnesses?
Not where the defence had a fair opportunity and chose not to use it. Here, the trial court had dismissed a recall petition in 2016, the High Court had upheld that order, and it had attained finality. The Court also invoked Section 33(5) POCSO, which obliges Special Courts to ensure a child is not called repeatedly to testify.
What is aggravated penetrative sexual assault under Section 5(l) POCSO?
Section 5(l) covers repeated penetrative sexual assault on the same child; it is punishable under Section 6. In this case the survivor's unchallenged testimony of repeated assaults during nine days in hotel rooms, corroborated by medical evidence and her family's testimony, sustained the Section 6 conviction. For offences committed in 2014, the pre-2019 minimum of ten years rigorous imprisonment applied.
Why was the Section 365 IPC conviction set aside?
Because Sections 365 and 366 IPC rested on the same single act of abduction. Convicting on both would punish one act twice under overlapping provisions, so only the Section 366 conviction survived, and any fine paid under Section 365 was ordered refunded.
Can an appellate court reduce a sentence while upholding conviction?
Yes. The Court reduced the Section 366 IPC sentence from ten years to three years rigorous imprisonment, noting the child was induced by a pretext rather than taken by force and no harm beyond the assault itself was shown, while leaving the ten-year POCSO sentence — the statutory minimum then applicable — untouched. Sentences run concurrently with set-off for custody undergone.