In State of U.P. v. Mohammad Azam Khan & Ors., 2026 INSC 1231 (decided 17 November 2026), a Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu dealt with three connected appeals arising from the Allahabad High Court's revisional orders in the dual birth-certificate case. The judgment is now a key reference on when a conviction — as distinct from a sentence — can be stayed while a criminal revision is pending, and on the role of parity under Article 14 in that exercise.
The background
FIR Case Crime No. 04 of 2019, P.S. Ganj, District Rampur, alleged a criminal conspiracy under Section 120B IPC, with Sections 420, 467, 468 and 471, over two conflicting birth certificates issued in the name of Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan — one from Rampur, one from Lucknow — and their alleged fraudulent use. The trial court convicted on 18 October 2023, and the appellate court affirmed on 23 December 2023. In revision, the Allahabad High Court, by a common judgment of 24 May 2024, suspended the sentences of all three convicts under Section 389(1) read with Sections 397/401 CrPC — but stayed only Mohammad Azam Khan's conviction, declining the same relief to his son and wife.
Three appeals reached the Supreme Court: the State challenged the stay granted to Azam Khan; Abdullah Azam Khan and Dr. Tazeen Fatma challenged the refusal of a stay to them.
The State's procedural objections failed
The State argued that Azam Khan's revision had sought only suspension of sentence, making the stay of conviction an order beyond the prayers, and that the High Court recorded no separate reasons for it. The Court rejected both points: the connected applications did seek interim relief, and the grounds the High Court gave for suspending sentence — time already served, age and ill health, no flight risk, and the absence of direct evidence that Azam Khan personally forged the municipal registers — were valid grounds for the stay as well.
Two lines drawn
On the Article 21 side, the Court recognised that a conviction inflicts immediate stigma and reputational harm that cannot be undone if the conviction is later set aside, and that judicial discretion must balance those irreversible consequences against the sanctity of a conviction until it is displaced. The Court quoted at length from Afzal Ansari v. State of U.P., (2024) 2 SCC 187, which in turn draws on Ravikant S. Patil v. Sarvabhouma S. Bagali, (2007) 1 SCC 673.
The outcome, party by party
| Party | Result |
|---|---|
| State of U.P. | Appeal dismissed — the stay of Azam Khan's conviction stands; no ground for interference under Article 136 |
| Mohammad Azam Khan | Stay of conviction granted by the High Court upheld |
| Abdullah Azam Khan | Appeal allowed — refusal of stay set aside as arbitrary; conviction stayed pending revision |
| Dr. Tazeen Fatma | Appeal allowed — same relief on parity |
The Court directed the High Court to decide the pending criminal revisions on their individual merits, uninfluenced by its observations, as expeditiously as possible.
Practice notes
For revision and appeal practice, three points stand out. First, a stay of conviction remains exceptional — counsel must plead the concrete, irreversible consequence the conviction is causing, not the election it is obstructing. Second, where interim relief has been granted to a similarly placed co-convict, parity is a constitutional argument, not a courtesy; conversely, a court refusing parity must articulate the differentia. Third, reasons given for suspending a sentence can, where they genuinely overlap, sustain a stay of conviction too — the absence of a separately labelled paragraph is not fatal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between suspension of sentence and stay of conviction?
Suspension of sentence pauses the punishment while an appeal or revision is pending; the conviction itself stands. A stay of conviction suspends the operative effect of the conviction — relevant to disqualifications, employment and electoral consequences. The Supreme Court reiterated that a stay of conviction is an exceptional remedy requiring distinct and compelling justification.
Can a conviction be stayed so that a person can contest elections?
Not on that ground alone. The Court unequivocally disavowed pleas for a stay based on political expediency, electoral ambitions or upcoming campaigns, observing that statutory powers cannot be leveraged to suit political calendars. Electoral consequences may exist, but they do not themselves supply the compelling justification the law demands.
What role does parity play in staying convictions of co-accused?
Parity is an aspect of Article 14. Where co-convicts stand on the same footing, a court granting a stay to one must either extend the same treatment to the others or record an intelligible differentia. In this case, the High Court's unreasoned refusal of a stay to two co-convicts, having granted it to the third, was held arbitrary and was set aside.
Under which provision is a stay of conviction sought today?
The power flows from Section 389(1) CrPC — now Section 430(1) BNSS, 2023 — in appeals, and is exercised alongside revisional powers (Sections 397/401 CrPC; Sections 438/442 BNSS). The tests developed in cases such as Ravikant S. Patil and Afzal Ansari continue to govern the discretion.