In Vivek Kumar Gautam v. State of NCT of Delhi (CRL.REV.P. 1011/2024 and 1016/2024, decided 19 November 2026), Justice Manmeet Pritam Singh Arora dismissed two revision petitions by a complainant who disputed the finding that the accused in his FIR was a child in conflict with law. The judgment works through the hierarchy of age-proof documents under Section 94 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, and settles two recurring procedural questions along the way.
The dispute
FIR No. 251/2020, PS North Rohini, was registered on the complainant's allegation that the accused and her relatives obstructed and assaulted him on 8 May 2020 and took his gold chain and purse — offences under Sections 188, 323, 341, 379 and 34 IPC, with Section 506 added later. The complainant and the accused had previously been engaged.
In September 2021 the accused claimed juvenility on the strength of a school leaving certificate recording her date of birth as 1 November 2003. A Magistrate declared her a child in conflict with law; the Sessions Court set that aside in June 2022 and remanded for a fresh inquiry; and on 27 September 2022 the Magistrate, after the Investigating Officer verified records from two schools, again declared her a child with the same date of birth. The complainant's challenge to that finding eventually reached the High Court in revision.
School records versus marriage records
The complainant's counter-case rested on documents giving the accused a date of birth of 1 November 1999: Arya Samaj Mandir records, a custody warrant, a 2021 marriage deed and a 2021 marriage certificate. The Court's analysis turned on chronology and the statutory hierarchy:
Two procedural rulings
First, on forum: the Court rejected the argument that only the Juvenile Justice Board could determine juvenility. Section 9(2) of the JJ Act expressly contemplates an age inquiry by a court other than the Board when the claim is raised before it, and Section 8(1)'s grant of exclusive jurisdiction to the Board is subject to the Act's other provisions.
Second, on participation: the complainant demanded cross-examination of the school principals and record keepers. Applying Rekha Murarka v. State of West Bengal, (2020) 2 SCC 474, the Court held that a complainant has no vested right to cross-examine at an age inquiry where the prosecution is satisfied with the verified documents — the inquiry under Section 94 is not a mini-trial.
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case | Vivek Kumar Gautam v. State of NCT of Delhi |
| Numbers | CRL.REV.P. 1011/2024 and 1016/2024 (under Section 102, JJ Act, 2015) |
| Judge | Justice Manmeet Pritam Singh Arora |
| Decided | 19 November 2026 (reserved 29 September 2026) |
| Outcome | Both revisions dismissed; juvenility finding upheld |
Takeaways for practitioners
Age challenges fail or succeed on the Section 94 hierarchy. A party attacking a school record must show a concrete deficiency in that record — not merely produce later documents pointing the other way, especially documents generated after the litigation began. Conversely, a party supporting juvenility should prove the school record through the issuing institution and trace it to its earliest source, as the Investigating Officer's verification across two schools did here. The second revision (against the appellate order terminating proceedings before the Board) fell automatically once the main challenge failed — a reminder to structure connected revisions so that each has an independent footing where possible.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which documents decide age under the JJ Act?
Section 94(2) sets a hierarchy: first, the date of birth certificate from the school or the matriculation certificate; failing that, a birth certificate from the corporation, municipal authority or panchayat; and only in their absence, ossification or other medical age tests. A consistent school record therefore ordinarily prevails over later-created documents.
Can only the Juvenile Justice Board decide a claim of juvenility?
No. The High Court held that Section 9(2) of the JJ Act permits a court other than the Board to inquire into a claim of juvenility raised before it. The Board's exclusive jurisdiction under Section 8(1) is expressly subject to the other provisions of the Act.
Does a complainant have a right to cross-examine on age documents?
Not as a matter of course. Relying on Rekha Murarka v. State of West Bengal, (2020) 2 SCC 474, the Court held the complainant had no vested right to cross-examine the school principals or record keepers where the prosecution was satisfied with the verified documents.
What if other documents show a different, older date of birth?
Their timing and provenance matter. Here, the documents showing a 1999 date of birth — marriage records and related papers — were created in 2020-21, after the dispute arose, while the school records giving a 2003 date of birth dated back to 2010-2015. The Court left the complainant to rely on the later documents in the separate FIR concerning the marriage.