In Poornima Gupta v. Saurav Gupta, 2026 INSC 1249 (Contempt Petition (C) No. 738 of 2026 in Transfer Petition (C) No. 235 of 2025, order dated 19 November 2026), a three-Judge Bench of Justices Vikram Nath, Sandeep Mehta and Aparesh Kumar Singh confronted a familiar and painful situation: a parent who breaches a court-recorded custody settlement and then pleads the child's own wishes in justification. The order is instructive on how the Supreme Court separates the contempt from the remedy.
The settlement and its breach
The parties had settled their disputes by a mutual settlement dated 13 November 2025, recorded by the Supreme Court on 12 December 2025 in a pending transfer petition. Under it, both children were to remain in the mother's custody; the father received visitation twice a year, four days at a time, at his parents' home in Dholpur, Rajasthan, and agreed to pay Rs 8,000 per month towards the children's education.
The mother's contempt petition alleged that on 22 July 2026 the father took the son from school and kept him in Rajasthan. Notice issued on 28 September 2026. The father's counter-affidavit did not deny the act; it justified it by the child's stated wish to stay with him and claimed the boy was now settled at Dholpur.
The in-chambers interaction
On 3 November 2026 the Bench interacted with the child in chambers. The order records a troubling impression: the child appeared "severely tutored" against his mother and sister, and insisted on staying with the father. The Court also recorded a prima facie observation — without any finding — that the father appeared to display signs of substance abuse.
Contempt found, enforcement calibrated
No punishment was imposed at this stage — the order is interim, and the contempt jurisdiction is being used as a lever to repair the situation rather than simply to punish the default.
Why this order matters in custody practice
Three features deserve attention. First, the Court refused to let the child's expressed preference launder the breach: the contempt finding came notwithstanding the child's insistence on staying with the father, precisely because tutoring was suspected. Second, the Court decoupled liability from remedy — a parent can be in clear contempt and yet immediate restitution may be withheld where the child's welfare demands a staged return. Third, the choice of a court-appointed counsellor, reporting in sealed cover on a fixed date, gives the arrangement structure and accountability that informal assurances never provide.
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case | Poornima Gupta v. Saurav Gupta, 2026 INSC 1249 |
| Proceeding | Contempt Petition (C) No. 738/2026 in T.P. (C) No. 235/2025 |
| Bench | Justices Vikram Nath, Sandeep Mehta and Aparesh Kumar Singh |
| Order dated | 19 November 2026 (interim) |
| Outcome | Clear contempt recorded; child counselling directed; report due 22 January 2027 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is breaching a custody settlement recorded by a court contempt?
Yes. A settlement recorded in a court order becomes an order of the court, and its breach is punishable as contempt. In this case the Court said in terms that the father was in clear contempt of the order of 12 December 2025, which gave the mother full custody and guardianship of both children.
Why did the Court not order the child's immediate return?
Because enforcement is shaped by the child's welfare, not only the parent's default. The Court noted after an in-chambers interaction that the child appeared severely tutored against his mother and sister, and held that an abrupt return risked lasting psychological harm. It chose counselling aimed at restoring trust before restoring custody.
Can a child's wish to stay with the defaulting parent justify the breach?
No. The father's counter-affidavit did not deny keeping the child and relied on the child's stated wish. The Court still recorded a clear contempt finding — the child's expressed preference, particularly where tutoring is suspected, does not legalise disobedience of a custody order.
What directions did the Supreme Court issue?
The Family Court at Dholpur is to engage a child counsellor, with the father bound to produce the child for sessions, not interfere, and bear the costs. The counsellor's sealed-cover report is due on 22 January 2027, with liberty for early listing if the child becomes ready to return to the mother. No punishment was imposed at this interim stage.