In Duryodhan Soren v. The State of Jharkhand (Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 999 of 2026, I.A. No. 13820 of 2026, order dated 19 November 2026), a Division Bench of Justices Rongon Mukhopadhyay and Ram Sharma of the Jharkhand High Court granted bail, pending appeal, to a man sentenced to twenty years rigorous imprisonment under Section 6 of the POCSO Act. The short order illustrates how appellate courts approach interim release after conviction in cases where the complainant's own evidence complicates the prosecution narrative.
The conviction under appeal
The appellant was convicted under Section 376(2)(n) IPC read with Sections 5(1) and 6 of the POCSO Act and sentenced to twenty years rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 20,000 in Special POCSO Case No. 103 of 2024 before the Special Judge, Dhanbad. The prosecution alleged that he forcibly established physical relations with the informant in December 2020 and thereafter on various occasions; she became pregnant, her parents were informed, a settlement followed, and the appellant married her. She gave birth to a son in August 2022 — after which, she alleged, he assaulted her and turned her out of the matrimonial home.
The bail application
With the appeal admitted and pending, the appellant sought bail. His counsel pointed to the trial evidence: the victim, examined as PW-1, and her mother, PW-2, had reiterated the FIR narrative — including the settlement, the marriage and the subsequent ouster. On that evidence, counsel argued, the case as it emerged at trial was of a marriage that later broke down, not of the offence as charged; and the appellant had remained on bail throughout the trial without incident. The State opposed.
The Division Bench noted that PW-1's evidence categorically revealed the marriage and the later ouster from the matrimonial house, and held it was inclined to admit the appellant to bail. Bail followed on a bond of Rs 10,000 with two sureties, to the satisfaction of the trial court, for the duration of the appeal. The order is interim: it records no view on the merits of the conviction.
Situating the order
Three strands of law intersect here, and it is worth keeping them distinct:
Practice perspective
For appellate counsel, the order underlines the value of building the bail application on the trial deposition rather than the FIR: what PW-1 and PW-2 actually said in court — not what the defence hopes to prove — is what moved the Bench. For complainants and the prosecution, it is a reminder that bail pending appeal in such cases is granted on light conditions precisely because the appeal remains fully open; any interference with the victim or breach of conditions can be brought back before the Division Bench.
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case | Duryodhan Soren v. The State of Jharkhand |
| Number | Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 999 of 2026; I.A. No. 13820 of 2026 |
| Bench | Justices Rongon Mukhopadhyay and Ram Sharma |
| Order dated | 19 November 2026 |
| Outcome | Bail granted pending appeal; bond of Rs 10,000 with two sureties |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a convict get bail while a criminal appeal is pending?
Yes. Appellate courts may suspend the sentence and release a convict on bail during the appeal — the power found in Section 389 CrPC, now Section 430 BNSS. For long sentences under special statutes like POCSO, courts look for features in the record that make the appeal genuinely arguable, beyond the mere filing of it.
What persuaded the Court to grant bail in this case?
The victim (PW-1) and her mother (PW-2) had themselves deposed to the sequence the defence relied on: a settlement after the pregnancy, marriage between the appellant and the victim, the birth of a child, and a later ouster from the matrimonial home. The Court also noted the appellant had remained on bail throughout the trial. On that record it was inclined to admit him to bail pending appeal.
Does marriage with the victim erase a POCSO offence?
No. POCSO offences are not compoundable, and courts — including a recent Kerala High Court Division Bench — have held that settlement or marriage does not by itself justify quashing. What a marriage and the victim's supportive testimony can do is bear on interim relief, such as bail pending appeal, and on the appellate court's eventual assessment of the evidence.
What conditions applied to the release?
Bail was granted on a bond of Rs 10,000 with two sureties of like amount to the satisfaction of the trial court — the Special Judge (POCSO), Dhanbad — during the pendency of the appeal. The conviction itself stands until the Division Bench decides the appeal on merits.