In Banmeet Singh v. Directorate of Enforcement (C-528 Nos. 1400 and 1355 of 2026 with connected bail applications, decided 17 November 2026), Justice Ravindra Maithani of the Uttarakhand High Court decided four connected matters arising from the Enforcement Directorate's money-laundering case against two brothers accused of running a dark-web drug operation and laundering the proceeds through Bitcoin. The judgment is a dense tour of remand law under the BNSS and the limits of custody-based bail arguments under the PMLA.
The allegations
The ED's case, recorded in ECIR/DNSZ0/04/2023, is that the two brothers ran a dark-web drug trafficking operation and laundered the sale proceeds through Bitcoin. Banmeet Singh had been arrested in the United Kingdom in 2019 on a United States extradition request, entered a plea in the US in January 2024, and was released in April 2024 — only to be arrested in India on arrival, in May 2024. The ED alleges a transfer of 4,250 BTC to his brother Parvinder, which remains unsecured; Parvinder surrendered 268.22 BTC, valued at about Rs 130.48 crore as of May 2024. Prosecution complaints were filed and cognizance taken in July 2024.
How the remand dispute arose
In May 2026 the Supreme Court set aside the cognizance order against Parvinder and directed fresh proceedings from that stage; the High Court did the same for Banmeet days later. Remand ran to 6 June 2026 — a holiday, followed by a Sunday. On 8 June the accused opposed remand through counsel, but only custody warrants were signed and no remand order was passed. On 12 June the Special Judge (PMLA), Dehradun, rejected their applications and remanded both to custody. Those orders — and the legality of the custody in the gap — were the heart of the challenge under Section 528 BNSS.
The Court's answers
Both Section 528 BNSS petitions were dismissed and both bail applications rejected.
What the judgment signals for PMLA defence work
First, remand-stage technicalities are a narrowing field: unless the defect is of the Article 22(1) communication variety — where Vihaan Kumar bites — courts are likely to treat later reasoned remands as curative. Second, custody-length arguments in economic offences must be built on trial-delay attribution, not bare arithmetic; here the Court found the scale of unsecured crypto-assets decisive the other way. Third, crypto-tracing is now central to both sides of a PMLA bail hearing: what has been surrendered, what remains unsecured, and what that says about flight risk and further laundering.
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case | Banmeet Singh v. Directorate of Enforcement (four connected matters) |
| Numbers | C-528 Nos. 1400 and 1355 of 2026; Third Bail Appln. 30 of 2026; First Bail Appln. 1825 of 2025 |
| Judge | Justice Ravindra Maithani |
| Decided | 17 November 2026 (reserved 30 October 2026) |
| Outcome | Petitions dismissed; bail rejected for both accused |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an accused be remanded before cognizance is taken on a PMLA complaint?
Yes. Relying on the line of authority from Suresh Kumar Bhikamchand Jain through Rahul Modi and Judgebir Singh, the Court held it settled that a remand order can be passed even when cognizance has not yet been taken on the complaint — the power to remand does not wait for cognizance.
Does a defect in one remand hearing make custody illegal?
Not by itself. Following Naranjan Singh Nathawan and Pranab Chatterjee, the Court held that a later valid remand order cures the irregularity of an earlier period. Here, no remand order was passed on 8 June 2026, but the Special Judge's reasoned remand of 12 June 2026 validated the custody; habeas-corpus era cases were distinguished.
Is the accused's physical presence required for extending judicial custody?
The Court accepted the rule in Jigar @ Jimmy Adatiya that the accused's presence — physical or virtual — is required for extension of custody. But where remand was actively opposed through counsel on the disputed date, no indefeasible right to release accrued from the lapse.
Why was bail refused despite the time in custody?
The Court weighed the transnational character of the alleged offence, the 4,250 Bitcoin said to remain unsecured, the surrendered Bitcoin worth about Rs 130 crore, and foreign remittances. It held there is no fixed rule converting delay into bail, and the custody period of either accused did not, in these circumstances, entitle them to bail.