Bar Council of India Notice

Disclaimer & Confirmation

As per the rules of the Bar Council of India, an advocate is not permitted to solicit work or advertise. By clicking “I Agree” below, you acknowledge and confirm that:

you are seeking information about Advocate Manish Jha of your own accord and for your own information and use; there has been no advertisement, personal communication, solicitation, invitation or inducement of any kind whatsoever from Advocate Manish Jha or the chamber to solicit any work through this website; the information made available here is provided only on your specific request; and no information on this website is to be construed as legal advice, nor does its use create any advocate-client relationship.

⚖  E-397, 4th Floor, Tagore Garden Extension, New Delhi – 110027 Mon–Sat  ·  +91 98738 50301  ·  legal@advocatemanishjha.com
Advocate Manish Jha Criminal · Civil · Family Law — New Delhi ☎  Consult the Chamber
Home › Arbitration Agreement Test
Delhi High Court · 19 November 2026

Headed "Arbitration", Held Not Arbitration: Section 7 Substance Over Labels

In Janvee Contracts v. Ahluwalia Contracts, the Delhi High Court refused to appoint an arbitrator where the clause provided only for amicable resolution in consultation with the respondent's own Chairman.

In Janvee Contracts Pvt Ltd v. Ahluwalia Contracts (India) Ltd (ARB.P. 1811/2026, decided 19 November 2026), Dr. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma of the High Court of Delhi dismissed a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, holding that the clause invoked — though headed "Arbitration and Resolution of Dispute" — was not an arbitration agreement within Section 7. The judgment is a crisp restatement of what separates adjudication from internal, consensual dispute mechanisms.

The clause in question

Ahluwalia Contracts issued a work order of about Rs 1.99 crore to Janvee Contracts in May 2021 for concrete mixing, transportation and pumping at a medical college project in Hamirpur. When Janvee raised claims of about Rs 19.30 lakh — including a security deposit of Rs 4.61 lakh — and invoked arbitration by a Section 21 notice, Ahluwalia replied that there was no arbitration agreement at all.

Clause 18 of the work order's Annexure-III, headed "Arbitration and Resolution of Dispute", said disputes would be "resolved amicably in consultation with Chairman-ACIL", whose decision would be final and binding. Clause 19 gave the courts of Delhi exclusive jurisdiction. The only issue before the Court: is Clause 18 an arbitration agreement under Section 7, so that an arbitrator can be appointed under Section 11(6)?

The Court's analysis

At the Section 11 stage the examination is confined to the prima facie existence of an arbitration agreement, per SBI General Insurance v. Krish Spinning, (2024) 12 SCC 1. Working from the classic attributes in K.K. Modi v. K.N. Modi, (1998) 3 SCC 573, and Jagdish Chander v. Ramesh Chander, (2007) 5 SCC 719, the Court found Clause 18 missing every marker of adjudication:

Consultation, not adjudication. The operative words provide for amicable resolution in consultation with the Chairman — no reference of disputes to him for decision, no submission of claims and defences, no procedure of hearing or evidence, no decision according to law.
No arbitral fallback. The clause contains no step referring disputes to arbitration if the amicable attempt fails.
An internal mechanism. The Chairman is an officer of one contracting party, which marks the process as internal rather than neutral adjudication.
Labels do not control. Neither the heading nor "final and binding" language converts consultation into arbitration — reinforced by Alchemist Hospitals v. ICT Health Technology, 2025 INSC 1289, where even repeated use of the word "arbitration" did not save the clause.

Reading Clauses 18 and 19 together sealed the conclusion: parties who had chosen the exclusive jurisdiction of Delhi courts for their disputes had not, in substance, agreed to arbitrate. The petition was dismissed, with liberty to pursue remedies in accordance with law and no observation on the merits.

Drafting lessons

This genre of litigation is almost entirely preventable at the drafting table. A workable arbitration clause does four things in one sentence: refers all disputes arising out of or in connection with the contract to arbitration; fixes the number and mode of appointment of arbitrators (or designates an institution such as DIAC); states the seat; and declares the award binding. Conversely, contractors reviewing standard-form work orders should flag "amicable resolution" clauses dressed in arbitral vocabulary — they leave the subcontractor with no tribunal and, as here, a dismissed petition a year after the Section 21 notice.

PointDetail
CaseJanvee Contracts Pvt Ltd v. Ahluwalia Contracts (India) Ltd
NumberARB.P. 1811/2026 (Section 11(6), Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996)
JudgeDr. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma
Decided19 November 2026 (reserved 30 October 2026)
OutcomePetition dismissed — no arbitration agreement under Section 7; remedies in law left open
For claim-holders in this position, the practical sequence is: re-check limitation for a civil or commercial suit immediately, since time spent on an abortive Section 11 petition is not automatically excluded; Section 14 of the Limitation Act, where it applies, must be specifically pleaded and proved.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes a clause an arbitration agreement under Section 7?

The clause must show an intention to submit disputes to an adjudicatory process: a neutral tribunal, a procedure under which both sides present their cases, and a decision rendered according to law that binds them. Attributes drawn from K.K. Modi v. K.N. Modi and Jagdish Chander v. Ramesh Chander remain the touchstone; headings and vocabulary do not control.

Is a decision by one party's Chairman ever arbitration?

A mechanism vesting the decision in an officer of one contracting party, with no submission of claims, no hearing and no adjudication according to law, is an internal dispute-resolution process, not arbitration. In this case the clause provided for disputes to be resolved amicably in consultation with the respondent's Chairman — consultation, not adjudication.

Does "final and binding" language make a clause arbitral?

No. The Court held finality language alone does not convert a consultative mechanism into arbitration. The Supreme Court's decision in M/s Alchemist Hospitals v. ICT Health Technology, 2025 INSC 1289, went further: even a clause titled "Arbitration" that used the word repeatedly was held not to be an arbitration agreement.

What remedies survive when a Section 11 petition is dismissed?

The claim itself is untouched. The Court expressly left the petitioner at liberty to pursue remedies available in law — typically a civil or commercial suit for recovery — and clarified that nothing in the judgment touched the merits of the claims or the defence. An exclusive-jurisdiction clause, like Clause 19 here, will guide where that suit is filed.

Note: This article is general information about the law and is not legal advice. It does not create an advocate-client relationship. The position stated is as at 21 November 2026 and may have changed since. Readers should verify any provision or decision referred to against the official text and seek advice on their own circumstances.