In four connected criminal revisions decided on 20 November 2026 (CRR 2180, 2181, 2303 and 2304 of 2023; 2026:CHC-AS:2010), Dr. Justice Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee of the Calcutta High Court declined to disturb an appellate order that had set aside a wife's interim maintenance while enhancing the two children's maintenance to Rs 25,000 each per month. The judgment is a useful statement of where interim maintenance stops and evidence begins — under both Section 125 CrPC and the DV Act.
The litigation web
The parties married in 2009 and have two children, born in 2014 and 2017. After the wife says she was driven from the matrimonial home in July 2020, the filings multiplied: a Section 498A IPC case (charge-sheeted and pending trial), a DV Act complaint, a Section 125 CrPC maintenance case, the husband's criminal complaint alleging misappropriation of Rs 75 lakh by the wife's father, a custody case, and a divorce petition stayed pending the alimony application.
On the interim-maintenance track, the trial court in June 2022 granted the wife Rs 20,000, Rs 15,000 per child, and an accommodation charge of Rs 25,000. In April 2023 the Additional Sessions Judge reworked that: the wife's interim maintenance was set aside, the children's was raised to Rs 25,000 each per month, and arrears were to be paid in five instalments. Both sides came to the High Court.
What the High Court held
Reading the decision with Rajnesh v. Neha
The only authority pressed was Rajnesh v. Neha, (2021) 2 SCC 324, the Supreme Court's framework judgment requiring affidavits of assets and liabilities from both sides in maintenance proceedings. This case illustrates the framework's limits as much as its force: affidavits put each side's financial picture on record, but where the pictures conflict root-and-branch — hidden accounts, routed funds, corporate shareholdings — the interim court takes a provisional view and leaves the truth to trial. The wife's interim award fell at the appellate stage because her own resources were apparent on the record; her final entitlement remains fully open.
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case | Mayur Agarwal v. Swati Agarwal (and cross-revisions) |
| Numbers | CRR 2180, 2181, 2303 and 2304 of 2023; 2026:CHC-AS:2010 |
| Judge | Dr. Justice Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee |
| Decided | 20 November 2026 (heard 15 June 2026) |
| Outcome | All four revisions dismissed; Rs 25,000 per child upheld; final applications to be decided on evidence, preferably in six months |
Practical pointers
For claimants: treat the Rajnesh affidavit as the centrepiece of the case, not a formality — gaps and inconsistencies in disclosure now cost interim relief, not just credibility at trial. For paying spouses: an attack on the other side's disclosure succeeds at the interim stage only to the extent the suppression is apparent from documents already on record; everything else is an argument for expedited evidence, which this judgment's six-month direction exemplifies. And for both: children's maintenance is insulated from the parents' financial warfare — courts will fix it by reference to actual, provable costs such as school fees.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can interim maintenance be refused because the wife has her own funds?
It can be reduced or set aside at the interim stage where the record shows substantial resources, but contested questions — whether income was suppressed, whether accounts are accessible, where funds came from — cannot be finally decided on affidavits. The High Court held those issues need examination and cross-examination at the evidence stage.
Are children's maintenance claims treated differently from the wife's?
Effectively, yes. The children's needs are concrete and immediate — here, school fees alone were about Rs 30,000 per month — so the Court upheld Rs 25,000 per child as not perverse even while the wife's own entitlement was left to trial. A father's grievance about not being consulted on school admission did not reduce the children's needs.
What is the duty of disclosure in maintenance litigation?
Both parties must disclose their actual earnings and assets, in line with Rajnesh v. Neha, (2021) 2 SCC 324, which mandates affidavits of assets and liabilities. The High Court endorsed the view that non-disclosure is akin to defrauding the court — a warning aimed at both spouses, not only the paying one.
How do Section 125 CrPC and DV Act maintenance interact?
They run in parallel; under Section 144 BNSS (the successor to Section 125 CrPC) and Sections 12, 20 and 23 of the DV Act, a court adjusts amounts so there is no double payment for the same need. In this case both proceedings were pending, and the High Court asked the trial courts to decide both, preferably within six months, on evidence.