Special leave petitions against interim orders — bail, suspension of sentence, stays of conviction — are filed every day, and most fail. Two Supreme Court decisions of mid-November 2026, read together, show with unusual clarity where the line runs: State of Goa v. Agniv Sengupta, 2026 INSC 1245 (16 November 2026), where the Court set aside a High Court bail order, and State of U.P. v. Mohammad Azam Khan, 2026 INSC 1231 (17 November 2026), where it refused to disturb a stay of conviction.
Two petitions, two fates
Both cases reached the Supreme Court by special leave against interim criminal orders, and both were State petitions. Their divergent outcomes were not inconsistency — they were the doctrine working as designed.
The working principle
Article 136 confers a discretionary, residual jurisdiction — not a further tier of appeal. Against interim orders, the Court's practice reduces to a question about the quality of the reasoning below, not the correctness of the outcome:
Drafting the SLP against an interim order
For the petitioner, the lesson is to locate the single load-bearing error: the SLP that catalogues twenty grievances about an interim order invites dismissal in limine, while the one that isolates the inference on which everything rests — and shows it to be legally impossible — fits the Agniv Sengupta mould. For the respondent defending an interim order, the strongest shield is the order's own reasoning: a High Court order that records the factors it weighed, as the Allahabad High Court did, is very difficult to dislodge. Counsel should also frame the consequence honestly — an interim order set aside is not a final loss, and the Supreme Court's standard practice of insulating the merits should be pressed into the order itself.
| Case | Interim order below | Result under Article 136 |
|---|---|---|
| State of Goa v. Agniv Sengupta, 2026 INSC 1245 | Bail granted by Bombay High Court | Set aside; surrender in three weeks |
| State of U.P. v. Mohammad Azam Khan, 2026 INSC 1231 | Stay of conviction by Allahabad High Court | Upheld; parity relief extended to co-convicts |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Article 136 lie against interim and interlocutory orders?
Yes — Article 136 is not confined to final judgments; it extends to any order of any court or tribunal. But the jurisdiction is discretionary and exceptional, and against interim orders the Court ordinarily declines to interfere unless the order is perverse, ignores binding principle, or causes grave injustice that cannot await the main proceeding.
Why did the bail order fall but the stay of conviction survive?
Because the defect alleged was different in kind. In Agniv Sengupta the High Court's bail grant rested on a single unsustainable inference — that a manager's duplicate keys disconnected the occupant from the recovery — which the Court found would make any hotel-room recovery unattributable. In Azam Khan the High Court had given valid reasons (age, health, time served, the state of the evidence), so the discretionary grant disclosed no ground for interference.
Is the test different when the State is the petitioner?
The threshold is the same, but the subject matter differs: when the State challenges bail or a stay, it must show the order is perverse or ignores relevant material, not merely that another view was possible. Both November decisions involved State petitions — one met the standard, the other did not.
Do observations made while deciding such SLPs bind the trial?
No. In both cases the Court confined its findings to the interim stage: Agniv Sengupta's possession question remains for trial, and the Allahabad High Court was directed to decide the pending revisions on their individual merits, uninfluenced by the Supreme Court's observations.