Can a defendant’s admissions in an earlier arbitration survive the award being set aside — and found a decree on admissions years later? In M/s Universal Steel Supply Co & Ors v. Pawan Kumar Saraf & Anr (RFA 370/2026, reserved 27 July, pronounced 17 November 2026), the Delhi High Court said yes. The appeal under Section 96 CPC challenged a possession decree passed under Order XII Rule 6 CPC by the District Judge, New Delhi, on 13 March 2026 in a suit concerning plot Y-7, Loha Mandi, Naraina. The appeal was dismissed, and the decree stands.
A thirty-year occupation, a sixteen-year suit
The defendants had occupied the Naraina plot since 1994 for an iron and steel business; the agreements lapsed in 2002–2004, a quit notice followed in 2005, an arbitration produced an award in 2006 that was set aside in 2010, and the possession suit (CS(OS) 1453/2010) worked its way to a decree on admissions in 2026. The appeal consolidated every surviving defence: want of a Section 106 TPA notice, the Rent Control bar, res judicata, and non-joinder of a co-owner.
The four holdings
The part that will be cited: admissions and the dead award
The appellants’ best point was conceptual: if the award died, surely the arbitration record died with it. The court separated the two. The findings of the arbitrator ceased to bind when the award was set aside; the admissions the defendants themselves made in their counter-statement of 1 April 2006 — acknowledging the commission arrangement — remained their own statements, usable against them like any other admission. Their written statement’s contrary story “stands belied by their own Counter-Statement”. On such clear and unequivocal admissions of the material facts — ownership, the character of occupation, the expiry of any authority to remain — Order XII Rule 6 was properly invoked, because a trial on admitted facts is an exercise in futility.
Lessons for property litigation
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the occupancy arrangement?
The plaintiffs said the defendants used a 225 sq. yd. portion of the plot to store and sell iron and steel under agreements from 1994, renewed until 2002, against commission of Rs 25 per metric tonne — a licence. The defendants said they were month-to-month tenants at Rs 2,500 per month. The court held the comprehensive reading of the documents showed an intention to create a licence, not a lease.
Why did the Delhi Rent Control Act not apply?
The property was open land with a temporary tin shed, which is not “premises” within Section 2(i) of the DRC Act. With the Section 50 bar inapplicable, the civil court had jurisdiction irrespective of whether the arrangement was a lease or a licence.
How did res judicata from the arbitration fail?
An arbitral award of 8 May 2006 had been set aside in 2010 on grounds concerning the independence of the arbitrator’s appointment — not on merits. The court held the award’s findings were no longer subsisting findings binding the parties, and the plea that the suit was barred by res judicata was without merit. The defendants had also never sought a Section 8 reference in the suit.
What justified a decree on admissions?
Order XII Rule 6 permits judgment where material facts stand clearly and unequivocally admitted. The defendants’ arbitration counter-statement of 1 April 2006 admitted the commission arrangement; the court held that setting aside the award “does not efface these admissions”, that the written statement’s denial stood belied by the defendants’ own document, and that recording evidence on admitted facts would be an exercise in futility.