Three bail applications had failed. The fourth succeeded — because the trial itself had changed. In Manoj Singh Thapa v. State (NCT of Delhi) & Anr (BAIL APPLN. 43/2026, order of 17 November 2026), the Delhi High Court considered the case of a father in custody since May 2023 under Sections 376 and 323 IPC and Section 6 of the POCSO Act (FIR No. 272/2023, PS Vasant Kunj South). By the time the fourth application was heard, the complainant had been examined as PW-1 and had not supported the prosecution; her mother had followed; and the complainant told the court directly that the allegations were false. Justice Mini Pushkarna granted bail.
A case that changed shape
The FIR began as a missing-person report: the petitioner himself reported his minor daughter missing in May 2023, and the case was first registered under Section 363 IPC. After she returned, her statements and a medical examination led to the addition of Section 376 IPC and Section 6 POCSO against the father. He was arrested on 16 May 2023, chargesheeted on 13 July 2023, and remained in custody through three unsuccessful bail attempts while the trial inched forward before the POCSO court at Patiala House.
The doctrine: change of circumstances
Successive bail applications occupy a disciplined middle ground. A fresh plea cannot re-argue what was already rejected; it must point to something new. The court quoted the settled formulation from Kalyan Chandra Sarkar — dismissal of an earlier application does not preclude a subsequent one where there is a material change — and found the test amply met:
The order and its conditions
Bail was granted on a personal bond of Rs 10,000 with one surety: conditions include cooperating with the investigation, maintaining a verified address and mobile number, no inducement or tampering, appearance when directed, and reporting to the local police station on the first Monday of each month. The cancellation clause is specific — a fresh FIR, DD entry or complaint against the petitioner opens the door for the State to seek recall.
Reading the case in context
With trials under the BNSS now listing victim testimony early in POCSO matters, orders like this one underline why the first prosecution witnesses often determine the custody question long before judgment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a fourth bail application even maintainable?
Yes. Successive bail applications are maintainable where there is a material change in circumstances. The court relied on Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan (2005): dismissal of an earlier application does not preclude a later one if circumstances have changed. Earlier applications here had been dismissed on 4 July 2024, 5 March 2025 and 2 September 2025.
What was the change in circumstances?
The principal witness — the victim — was examined and did not support the prosecution in depositions recorded on 1 October 2024 and 9 July 2025, denying the allegations; her mother (PW-2) also did not support the case and questioned the recorded birth year. Only 2 of 15 prosecution witnesses had been examined, and the State ultimately had no serious objection to bail.
What precedents guided the court?
Besides Kalyan Chandra Sarkar, the court followed its own bail order in Shree Krishan v. State (19 November 2025), a comparable case of a father released after the victims resiled, and noted a Supreme Court order of 10 August 2026 in Jeetram v. State of Rajasthan (SLP (Crl.) 8875/2026) granting bail where the victim had turned hostile and her age was in issue.
Does hostile testimony end the case?
No. A hostile witness’s evidence is not effaced; the trial continues and the court may still rely on parts of it. The bail order is confined to liberty pending trial — the court expressly recorded that its observations are not an opinion on the merits, and the State may seek cancellation if any fresh complaint or FIR is registered against the accused.