A woman’s body was found stuffed in an iron drum near a lime kiln in Karnataka in September 2013. The trial court convicted the appellant of her murder and the High Court affirmed. On 18 November 2026, in Bheemanagouda @ Bheemajja v. State by Harapanahalli Police (Criminal Appeal No. 5402 of 2026, arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 13798 of 2025; 2026 INSC 1239), a Bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Vipul M. Pancholi acquitted him, finding that the circumstantial chain was “not complete and unbroken” at every link — motive, last-seen evidence, and the recovery of the deceased’s ornaments.
The prosecution’s story
The body of Sharadamma, wife of PW-7, was discovered on 5 September 2013. The prosecution alleged that the appellant, said to be in an illicit relationship with her, suspected her of another affair, strangled her on the night of 4 September 2013, robbed her of her ornaments and concealed the body in a drum. He was arrested on 12 September 2013, and the police claimed the ornaments were recovered from a trunk at his house on his disclosure.
Four links, each tested and found wanting
Applying the five golden principles of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda, the Court worked through the chain circumstance by circumstance:
The Sanwat Khan principle
The judgment’s most practically useful holding concerns what a recovery can and cannot prove. Unexplained possession of a deceased’s articles triggers only the presumption in Illustration (a) to Section 114 of the Evidence Act: that the possessor is either the thief or a receiver of stolen property. To travel from theft to murder, the prosecution must prove that the theft and the homicide formed part of the same transaction. Here it could not — and, tellingly, no charge of theft or robbery had been framed at all. The appellant’s acquittal under Section 201 IPC had also attained finality because the State never appealed it, leaving the prosecution in the odd position of a murder conviction standing alone.
“May be” is not “must be”
Quoting Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade, the Court recalled the mental distance between “may have committed the offence” and “must have committed the offence”. A circumstantial case succeeds only when every hypothesis except guilt is excluded. Finding the chain broken at several links, the Court quashed the conviction and the life sentence, acquitted the appellant of the Section 302 IPC charge, and directed his release forthwith unless required in another case.
What the decision signals for appellate practice
Frequently Asked Questions
What had the lower courts held?
The Additional District & Sessions Judge, Davanagere (Sessions Case No. 101 of 2014, judgment of 27 April 2017) convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to life imprisonment with a Rs 25,000 fine, while acquitting him under Section 201 IPC. The Karnataka High Court dismissed his appeal (Criminal Appeal No. 1355 of 2017) on 9 July 2024. The Supreme Court has now set aside the conviction.
Why did the last-seen evidence fail?
The statements of the two last-seen witnesses were recorded 58 days after the incident. The trial court itself had rejected their testimony for that reason, and the High Court reversed that finding without addressing the delay. The Supreme Court held the last-seen circumstance was not conclusively established and had been rightly rejected by the trial court.
What is the rule on recovered articles of the deceased?
Following the line of authority in Sanwat Khan, the Court held that unexplained possession of a deceased’s belongings enables only the presumption under Illustration (a) to Section 114 of the Evidence Act — that the possessor is a thief or receiver. It cannot be stretched to an inference of murder unless the prosecution proves the theft and the killing were one transaction. Here, no theft or robbery charge was even framed.
What are the equivalent provisions under the new codes?
For offences after 1 July 2024, Section 302 IPC corresponds to Section 103(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and Section 201 IPC to Section 238 BNS. Police statements under Section 161 CrPC are now recorded under Section 180 BNSS, and the disclosure-recovery rule in Section 27 of the Evidence Act is carried into the proviso to Section 23(2) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.