When elderly parents contemplate a maintenance claim, the instinct — cultural more than legal — is to look only at sons. The statutes are not so limited. Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita speaks of “any person” who, having sufficient means, neglects to maintain “his or her father or mother”; the words accommodate daughters as naturally as sons. Hindu law and the Senior Citizens Act, 2007 are even more explicit. This explainer maps the daughter’s obligation, the effect of her marriage, and the defences that genuinely work.
The three statutory sources
What “unable to maintain themselves” means for parents
The parent’s inability is assessed realistically, not theoretically. A small pension or rental income does not disqualify a parent whose medical and living costs exceed it; conversely, parents holding substantial income-yielding assets will struggle to show inability. Counsel for parents should file a candid statement of income, expenses and health costs — credibility at this threshold decides the case’s temperature. Counsel for the daughter should obtain discovery of the parents’ actual holdings, including property transferred to other siblings, which is often the real grievance driving the petition.
The daughter’s means: the real battleground
Because liability follows means, the contest in daughter cases is almost always evidentiary. Three propositions frame it. First, only the daughter’s own income and assets count; a Magistrate cannot indirectly charge the son-in-law. Second, “means” is not limited to salary — earning capacity, professional qualifications and property all enter the assessment, as they do for sons. Third, the daughter’s own obligations — her children’s education, dependent in-laws, EMIs — are relevant to quantum, not to liability. The order that emerges is typically a modest monthly figure calibrated to leave her household functional.
Defences that work, and ones that do not
| Defence | Prospects |
|---|---|
| “I have no independent income” | Good, if true and proved — liability needs means |
| “My siblings should share” | Good for apportionment; no answer to liability itself |
| “The parents gave all property to my brother” | Relevant equity; courts may direct the propertied sibling to bear more, and the parents’ Section 23 (2007 Act) remedy against that transfer may be the better route |
| “I am married and belong to another family” | Fails — marriage does not dissolve the parent-child obligation |
| “The parents treated me badly” | Rarely succeeds against genuine destitution; the remedy is calibrated quantum, not denial |
Choosing the forum
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a daughter liable to maintain her parents under the BNSS?
Yes. Section 144(1)(d) BNSS — like Section 125(1)(d) CrPC before it — obliges a person having sufficient means to maintain a father or mother unable to maintain themselves, and the provision uses “his or her” language throughout. The liability attaches to the child’s means, not the child’s gender.
Does marriage extinguish or reduce a daughter’s liability?
It extinguishes nothing. Marriage changes a daughter’s household, not her parentage. What it can affect is quantum: a daughter without independent income cannot be ordered to pay out of her husband’s money, so the inquiry focuses on her own earnings and assets. A married daughter with her own salary, business or property is as answerable as a son with the same means.
What do Hindu law and the Senior Citizens Act add?
Section 20(3) HAMA obliges a Hindu to maintain aged or infirm parents who cannot maintain themselves out of their own earnings and property — an obligation the section expressly extends to daughters. The Senior Citizens Act defines “children” to include sons, daughters, grandsons and granddaughters, and its Section 4 obligation extends to such of them as would inherit the senior citizen’s property — with the Tribunal route offering summary, time-bound relief.
Can parents with multiple children pick just one to sue?
They may proceed against any child with means, but the respondent can — and should — seek that the burden be shared, bringing the siblings’ means on record. Tribunals and Magistrates routinely apportion the monthly figure among earning children rather than loading one, though a child cannot escape merely because others also neglected the parents.