When a terror investigation spans several States, the first battles are fought over geography: which FIRs travel, to which court, and whether separate cases may be tried together. In Union of India v. Arif Nisar @ Sahil (Transfer Petition (Crl.) Nos. 497-498 of 2026, 2026 INSC 1210, decided 16 November 2026), the Supreme Court allowed the Union's petitions to transfer an FIR pending in Srinagar and another in Faridabad to the NIA Special Court at Patiala House, New Delhi, and to club them with the NIA's Lal Qila blast case — treating all three as limbs of one alleged conspiracy.
Three cases, three forums
The NIA's case — RC-21/2025/NIA/DLI2, arising from the Lal Qila blast — stood registered under Sections 103(1), 109(1) and 61(2) of the BNS, Sections 16 and 18 of the UAPA and Sections 3 and 4 of the Explosive Substances Act, pending before the NIA Special Court at Patiala House. Two connected state cases, however, were travelling separately: FIR 162/2025 of P.S. Nowgam, Srinagar, before the ASJ (TADA/POTA) at Srinagar, and FIR 229/2025 of P.S. Dhauj, Faridabad, before the JMIC at Faridabad. The Central Government issued takeover orders under Section 6(5) of the NIA Act in December 2025 and January 2026, and the Union then sought transfer and clubbing from the Supreme Court.
The Court's reasoning
Why consolidation matters in conspiracy trials
| Fragmented trials | Consolidated trial |
|---|---|
| The same witnesses testify in three courts, with inconsistency risks | Evidence recorded once before one Special Court |
| Possibility of conflicting findings on the same conspiracy | One record, one set of findings |
| High-risk prisoner movement across States for every hearing | Reduced movement and security exposure |
| Parallel bail and interim orders in different forums | A single court seized of all interlocutory questions |
For practitioners: transfer and clubbing petitions of this kind turn on the documentary architecture — the Section 6(5) takeover orders, the MHA's connected-offence determinations, and a concrete showing of common accused and witnesses. For the defence, the battleground that remains is at trial: consolidation does not dilute the prosecution's burden to prove each accused's role in each offence, and severance arguments can still be pressed where prejudice from a joint trial is shown.
The judgment also clarifies the reach of Khimji Bhai Jadeja: its discipline about same-transaction joinder does not fetter the Supreme Court's power to consolidate cases alleged to be parts of a single larger conspiracy. Forum questions settled, the Lal Qila blast prosecution now proceeds as one trial.
Frequently Asked Questions
Under what power were the cases transferred?
The Union invoked Section 13(2) of the NIA Act, 2008 — which provides for trial of scheduled offences by Special Courts — read with Section 446 of the BNSS (the Supreme Court's transfer power, formerly Section 406 CrPC) and the Supreme Court Rules. The Centre had also issued orders under Section 6(5) of the NIA Act directing the NIA to take over the two state investigations.
What satisfied the Court that the cases were connected?
The Ministry of Home Affairs orders treated the FIRs as connected offences, and the Court found common accused, common witnesses and overlapping evidence across the three cases. Separate trials would have risked multiplicity of proceedings, conflicting findings and avoidable security concerns in moving accused and witnesses between distant courts.
What was the objection to clubbing, and why did it fail?
The respondents relied on State (NCT of Delhi) v. Khimji Bhai Jadeja, which deals with trying offences forming the same transaction. The Court distinguished it: the petitioner's case was a larger conspiracy spanning the separate FIRs, not merely one series of transactions, and it followed its own June 2026 order in NIA v. Rahul @ Faisal Karim Masud, which had transferred West Bengal cases to the same Special Court.
Does transfer and clubbing decide anyone's guilt?
No. The order is purely procedural: it fixes the forum and consolidates the proceedings. The charges — under the BNS, the UAPA and the Explosive Substances Act — remain to be proved at trial before the Special Court, where the accused retain every defence.