A criminal trial can survive many setbacks, but it cannot survive the disappearance of its evidence. In Naresh v. State of Haryana (Criminal Appeal Nos. 1137-1138 of 2014, 2026 INSC 1220, decided 16 November 2026), the Supreme Court acquitted a man convicted of the 2011 murder of two women in village Ranila, Bhiwani — a conviction that began with a death sentence, was commuted to life by the High Court, and has now fallen entirely, because every private eyewitness turned hostile and what remained were police statements the law does not permit to be used as proof.
A case that climbed the entire ladder
Two widows, Suman and Shakuntla, were found dead on the night of 17 April 2011. FIR No. 23 of 2011 at P.S. Baund Kalan named the appellant under Section 302 IPC on the basis of a statement by a witness who had not seen the incident. The trial court convicted both accused in 2013 and sentenced them to death; the Punjab and Haryana High Court, in the murder reference, confirmed the appellant's conviction under Sections 302, 449, 297 and 201 IPC but commuted the death sentence to life, while acquitting the co-accused. The appeals reached the Supreme Court through the Supreme Court Legal Services Committee, leave being granted in 2014; the Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh decided them on 16 November 2026.
What the prosecution was left with
At trial, the private witnesses turned hostile. The case then rested on their Section 161 statements, disclosure statements, the recovery of a danda and a gandasi, and forensic reports that were inconclusive.
The conviction's logic
The witnesses had told the police a coherent story; their police statements, the recoveries and the post-mortem could together carry the case despite the courtroom retractions.
The Supreme Court's holding
Section 162 CrPC bars use of police statements "for any purpose" except contradiction; a proved contradiction impeaches credit under Section 155(3) of the Evidence Act but proves nothing. With the recoveries not proved under Section 27 and circumstances not put under Section 313, no legal evidence remained.
The Court traced the rule to Tahsildar Singh v. State of U.P. and V.K. Mishra v. State of Uttarakhand (paras 31-33), noted that statements under Section 164 CrPC stand on a better footing than Section 161 statements (para 34), and dismantled the prosecution's reliance on a key witness's statement recorded five days after the incident (paras 37-38). The concurrent findings were interfered with; the convictions and sentences under Sections 302, 449, 297 and 201 were set aside and the appellant acquitted, with the trial court's compensation direction also vacated — and the DLSA, Bhiwani asked to consider the victims' family under the compensation scheme now housed in Section 396 BNSS.
The doctrinal core
| Material | Permissible use at trial |
|---|---|
| Section 161 CrPC / Section 180 BNSS statement | Contradiction of the maker only — never substantive proof |
| Proved contradiction | Impeaches credit (Evidence Act s.155(3) / BSA equivalent); does not prove the earlier version |
| Section 164 CrPC / Section 183 BNSS statement | Better footing, but still not substantive evidence by itself |
| Disclosure and recovery | Admissible only to the extent proved under Evidence Act s.27 discipline |
For appellate practice: where a conviction survives on hostile-witness records, the appeal should isolate each item the courts below treated as evidence and ask the statutory question — under what provision is this admissible, and for what purpose? Convictions that cannot answer that question for their load-bearing material are vulnerable even at the Article 136 stage, concurrent findings notwithstanding.
The judgment is also a sobering institutional document: a man sentenced to death in 2013 has been acquitted thirteen years after the trial began, because the legal character of police statements was mistaken at every stage below. The discipline of Sections 161 and 162 — carried into the BNSS — exists precisely to prevent investigation records from quietly becoming proof.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Section 161 statement and why can it not prove guilt?
It is a statement recorded by the police during investigation (now Section 180 BNSS). Section 162 CrPC bars its use at trial for any purpose except contradicting the witness who made it. Even when a contradiction is proved, the effect is only to impeach the witness's credit — the earlier statement does not become evidence of the facts it narrates.
If witnesses turn hostile, is the prosecution case over?
Not automatically. A hostile witness's evidence is not wiped out; the parts that survive cross-examination can be relied on, and other evidence — recoveries proved under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, forensic links, circumstantial chains — can still sustain a conviction. The acquittal here followed because those other limbs also failed: the recoveries were not proved, the forensic evidence was inconclusive, and incriminating circumstances were not put to the accused under Section 313.
Why did the Supreme Court interfere with concurrent findings?
Article 136 interference with concurrent findings is exceptional, but it is warranted where the conviction rests on legally impermissible material. Once the Section 161 statements were excluded from the substantive record, there was nothing lawful left to support the conviction — a question of law, not a re-appreciation of credible evidence.
What happens to the victims' family after an acquittal?
The Court set aside the compensation ordered against the appellant but asked the District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani to consider the family's case under the victim compensation scheme — under Section 357A CrPC, now Section 396 BNSS — which operates independently of any conviction.