Matrimonial disputes rarely stay in one courtroom. A Domestic Violence Act complaint, maintenance orders, appeals and cross-petitions can multiply across forums until no single court can end the conflict. In Ankit Saraiya v. Pooja Saraiya (2026 INSC 1227, decided 16 November 2026), the Supreme Court showed how such a web is unwound: a negotiated settlement recorded before the Court, a divorce granted directly under Article 142 of the Constitution, and about fourteen listed proceedings between the parties brought to a close in one order.
The litigation the settlement ended
The parties married on 31 January 2013; a son was born in 2017. The wife's complaint under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (Complaint No. 989 of 2020) led, on 12 February 2025, to a trial court order of Rs 1.5 lakh per month covering maintenance for the child and alternative accommodation. The husband applied under Section 25(2) to alter that order; an advocate commissioner's inquiry followed, which the First Appellate Court set aside in December 2025. The Calcutta High Court, in C.R.R. No. 553 of 2026, treated that challenge as infructuous while leaving the accommodation charges open — and the husband carried the matter to the Supreme Court by special leave.
From appeal to settlement
Before the Bench of Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, the case changed character. Rather than adjudicate another slice of the dispute, the Court directed the parties to explore settlement. They returned with comprehensive terms, which the judgment records and makes part of the order.
Rs 30 crore
Permanent alimony to the wife in full and final settlement of her claims.
Rs 45 crore
Held in trust for the child, securing his maintenance, education and future.
Residence
A defined residence right for the wife, subject to recorded conditions.
14 cases
The listed proceedings between the parties and their families brought to a close.
The settlement also preserved a parenting plan for the child, with a good-faith consultation mechanism for future disagreements — a detail worth noting, because financial settlements that ignore parenting questions tend to generate the next round of litigation.
Article 142: the power to finish the matter
Two further steps gave the settlement finality. First, invoking Article 142 of the Constitution, the Court gave quietus to all the disputes covered by the terms. Second — and decisively — it dissolved the marriage itself under Article 142 and directed that a decree be drawn, without remitting the parties to a mutual-consent petition before the Family Court. The appeal and all pending applications were disposed of in terms of the settlement.
The DV Act proceeding that began this litigation was designed to secure interim protection, not to end a marriage. But once spouses reach genuine terms, Article 142 lets the Supreme Court do what no single forum below could: dissolve the marriage, settle the money, fix the parenting arrangement and close every connected case in one order.
What this means for litigants
For parties locked in multi-forum matrimonial conflict: the lesson is structural. Interim orders — maintenance, accommodation charges, commissioner inquiries — are pressure points, not endpoints. A settlement negotiated when the matter reaches a court that can bind everything at once is worth far more than piecemeal victories below. Listing every pending case in the settlement schedule, securing the child's provision separately from the spouse's, and recording the terms in the court's order are what convert a truce into a conclusion.
Few families litigate at these figures, but the architecture of the order — alimony, a child's trust, a residence right, a parenting plan and a schedule of closed cases — is a template that scales to any matrimonial settlement, whatever the amounts involved.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the Supreme Court grant a divorce without the parties going back to the Family Court?
Yes. Under Article 142 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court can pass any order necessary to do complete justice in a pending matter, and it has repeatedly used that power to dissolve marriages where the parties have settled or the marriage has broken down irretrievably — sparing them a fresh round of mutual-consent proceedings below.
What did the settlement in this case provide?
As recorded in the judgment, the terms included permanent alimony of Rs 30 crore to the wife, Rs 45 crore to be held in trust for the child, a defined residence right for the wife subject to conditions, a parenting plan with a good-faith process for future disagreements, and the closure of the listed proceedings pending between the parties and their families.
How did a trial court maintenance order become a Supreme Court appeal?
The wife's Section 12 DV Act complaint produced an interim order of Rs 1.5 lakh per month covering child maintenance and alternative accommodation. The husband's application under Section 25(2) led to an inquiry that the First Appellate Court set aside, and the Calcutta High Court's revisional order in turn was carried to the Supreme Court — where the Court steered the parties toward settlement instead of another round on the merits.
Is a settlement recorded by the Supreme Court enforceable?
Yes. Once the settlement is made part of the Court's order, its terms operate as directions of the Supreme Court. A breach can be pursued through enforcement or contempt proceedings rather than by starting fresh litigation on the underlying disputes.