Revisional jurisdiction in cheque cases is a narrow corridor: the High Court corrects jurisdictional error and perversity, not evidence that was never led. Satish Saxsena & Anr v. State of NCT of Delhi & Anr (CRL.REV. P. (NI) 356/2026, reserved 29 October, pronounced 17 November 2026) shows what happens when a defence is assembled after the fact. The petitioner’s conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 — six months’ simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs 10 lakh — was affirmed through trial, appeal and now revision under Section 528 BNSS.
Two defences, both late
The accused, a tenant of the complainant since 2018, ran two inconsistent explanations for the Rs 7 lakh received by bank transfer: that the first tranche paid for sanitary goods, and that the cheques were mere security under a lease agreement. The High Court’s judgment is a study in how each failed for want of foundation rather than want of imagination.
The discipline of secondary evidence
The judgment turns substantially on a procedural rule that decides more cheque trials than any presumption: a party relying on a document must prove it. A photocopy is secondary evidence, admissible only through the gateway conditions of the Evidence Act — which required, at minimum, a notice to the opposite party to produce the original. None was given. Nor was the document put to the complainant in cross-examination, so the defence narrative was never tested against the person best placed to deny it. By the time the plea matured in revision, it was argument without evidence.
Timing is the other half of credibility
Delhi courts consistently treat the reply to the statutory demand notice, and the accused’s plea when notice is framed under Section 251 CrPC (now Section 274 BNSS for post-July 2024 trials), as the natural moments for a genuine defence to surface. A defence appearing for the first time at trial — or in appeal — starts with a credibility deficit that documentary corroboration alone can repair. Here there was neither timing nor corroboration.
The endgame
Frequently Asked Questions
What were the facts?
The complainant transferred Rs 3 lakh and Rs 4 lakh to the accused’s bank account in early 2022. Two cheques for those amounts were returned “Funds Insufficient” in February and March 2023, and a legal notice of 9 April 2023 went unpaid. The trial court (JMFC NI Act, Dwarka) convicted; the Appellate Court (ASJ-03, South-West, Dwarka) upheld the conviction on 7 September 2026; the High Court has now dismissed the revision.
Why did the security-cheque defence fail?
The accused claimed the cheques were security for a lease deposit under a lease agreement dated 1 September 2022 — but produced only an unstamped photocopy, never produced the original, gave no notice to produce under Section 65 of the Evidence Act, and never confronted the complainant with the document in cross-examination. The courts declined to act on it.
What about the plea that the money was for goods?
The accused said the transfers paid for sanitary goods supplied without tax invoices. The court called this a bald averment: no bills, GST records or transport receipts were produced, and the plea featured neither in a reply to the statutory notice nor at the stage of framing of notice under Section 251 CrPC. It was treated as an afterthought.
What is the statutory presumption at play?
Once signature and issuance are admitted, Sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act presume the cheque was issued for a legally enforceable debt; the accused must rebut this on a preponderance of probabilities with credible material. Bank-routed transfers also neutralised the challenge to the complainant’s financial capacity.