Indian maintenance law makes one point with unusual textual clarity: the child’s plate comes before the parents’ legal relationship. Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — like Section 125 CrPC before it — obliges a person with sufficient means to maintain his or her “legitimate or illegitimate minor child” unable to maintain itself. The words are the legislature’s own, and they decide the threshold question before it is asked: a child born outside marriage claims maintenance as of right, not as a concession.
The statutory foundations
Three regimes converge on the same answer. The secular, summary remedy is Section 144 BNSS: a Magistrate of the first class may order monthly maintenance where a person having sufficient means neglects or refuses to maintain, among others, a legitimate or illegitimate minor child unable to maintain itself — and an adult child so disabled. The personal-law route for Hindus is Section 20 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, which binds a Hindu, male or female, to maintain legitimate and illegitimate children during minority, with a daughter’s claim extending until marriage where she cannot maintain herself. And where the facts disclose domestic violence within a domestic relationship, monetary relief under Section 20 of the DV Act can carry the child’s expenses as well.
| Route | Who is bound | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Section 144 BNSS | Any person with sufficient means, any religion | Summary, speedy, enforceable by warrant; interim maintenance available |
| Section 20 HAMA | Hindu parents — father and mother alike | Civil obligation; quantum flexible; daughter’s claim till marriage |
| Section 20 DV Act | Respondent in a domestic relationship | Child’s expenses as part of monetary relief, with interim orders under Section 23 |
The paternity question — handled, not feared
Denial of paternity is the standard defence, and courts have a standard method. The claim is decided on preponderance of probabilities, as a civil-standard inquiry inside a summary proceeding: evidence of the relationship and cohabitation, hospital and municipal birth records naming the father, school records, photographs, correspondence and financial support already extended all count. Scientific testing is available but not automatic; courts weigh the child’s welfare and dignity before directing a DNA test, and treat an unjustified refusal to participate as a circumstance against the refusing party. Two practice realities deserve emphasis: first, the maintenance court’s finding on paternity is for the purpose of maintenance and does not conclusively settle status for all purposes; second, interim maintenance does not wait for the paternity trial — courts can and do grant interim relief on a prima facie view, precisely because a child cannot be fed retrospectively.
Quantum and enforcement
Once liability is found, the computation is the ordinary one: the child’s reasonable needs measured against the payer’s means, awarded ordinarily from the date of application. Education costs loom largest in practice — fees, transport, tuition — and courts increasingly provide for them specifically rather than inside a lump monthly figure. Enforcement follows the Section 144 machinery: warrants for levy of the amount due, and, for continued default, detention; arrears applications should be made with the discipline the statute’s limitation demands.
Claimant’s side: file through the mother as next friend, annex the birth record, plead the relationship with dates, and seek interim maintenance at the first hearing.
Respondent’s side: a paternity denial should be accompanied by engagement with the record — bald denial against documents invites adverse findings, and obstruction of testing can do the same.
Both sides: keep the child’s claim conceptually separate from the mother’s; the strength or weakness of one does not travel to the other.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which provisions give a child born outside marriage a maintenance claim?
Section 144(1) BNSS (formerly Section 125 CrPC) expressly covers the legitimate or illegitimate minor child, and extends to adult children unable to maintain themselves by reason of physical or mental abnormality or injury. Section 20 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 separately obliges a Hindu to maintain legitimate and illegitimate children during minority. The DV Act’s monetary relief can also include the children’s expenses where its ingredients are met.
Who files the claim?
The child, through the mother or other guardian as next friend. The mother’s own entitlement is a separate question — her claim as a “wife” depends on marriage, but the child’s claim does not, and the two are decided independently.
What happens when the alleged father denies paternity?
The court decides on the material: birth records, cohabitation evidence, correspondence and conduct. DNA testing can be directed, but courts order it cautiously, balancing the child’s interests, the presumption of legitimacy where a marriage exists, and privacy — a refusal to undergo a test the court finds justified can invite an adverse inference.
How is the amount fixed?
On the same principles as any child maintenance claim: the child’s reasonable needs — food, housing, education, medical care — against the payer’s means, ordinarily from the date of application. The child’s parentage has no bearing on quantum; the statute draws no distinction, and neither may the court.