A registration certificate is powerful paper — but it cannot manufacture a marriage the statute does not recognise. In A. Naveen Kumar v. K. Vigneswari (A.S. No. 79 of 2020, reserved 4 November, pronounced 19 November 2026), a Division Bench of the Madras High Court comprising Justices C.V. Karthikeyan and S. Raveekumar allowed a first appeal under Section 96 CPC read with Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, set aside the Family Court’s decree, and declared a marriage registered under the Hindu Marriage Act in 2009 null and void — because the man was a Christian, and the Act permits solemnisation only between two Hindus.
The factual knot
The parties’ accounts could hardly have differed more. The plaintiff said he was taken to the Registrar’s office on 20 February 2009 to sign as a witness and discovered later that a marriage had been registered; the parties, he said, never lived together. The respondent said the parties agreed to marry and registered the marriage before friends, and that dowry demands followed. What ultimately decided the appeal was neither narrative, but a question of status: was the plaintiff a Hindu at all on the date of registration?
Proving religion in court
The Bench’s treatment of the conversion evidence deserves attention. The trial court had seized on “two dates” of baptism as a contradiction; the Bench found they were two baptisms — Catholic in 1998, Pentecostal in 2006 — each supported by certificates, including those of the plaintiff’s parents, and consistent cross-examination. Equally significant is what the court refused to count: names and entries in Aadhaar or ration cards do not fix a person’s faith. Religious identity is a matter of belief and practice, proved like any other fact.
Section 5 is a gate, Section 8 only a register
The respondent’s own cross-examination conceded that no marriage ceremony took place and that the affirmative entry was made “for registration purposes”. With no solemnisation and no capacity under Section 5, there was nothing for the register to record: the Bench declared the entry at Serial No. 157 of 2009 null and void.
Why the case matters beyond Chennai
Sixteen years elapsed between registration and the declaration of nullity — a caution, in any jurisdiction, about how long a paper marriage can shadow a life.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the dispute?
The plaintiff sued in the Family Court, Chennai (O.S. No. 96 of 2010) for a declaration that a marriage registered on 20 February 2009 (Serial No. 157 of 2009, Chennai Central) was null and void, saying he was a baptised Christian, no ceremony ever took place, and he had been made to sign at the Registrar’s office believing he was a witness. The Family Court disbelieved his conversion case and dismissed the suit on 13 November 2019; the Division Bench has now reversed it.
How was the plaintiff’s religion decided?
The trial court had treated contradictions about baptism dates as fatal, but the Bench found they related to two separate baptisms (1998 and 2006), supported by certificates and cross-examination. The court held that a person’s name, or entries in government records such as Aadhaar or ration cards, cannot determine religious identity. The plaintiff was held to be a Christian at the time of registration.
Why does an interfaith registration under the HMA fail?
Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act opens with marriage “between any two Hindus”. Reading Sections 5 and 8 together, the Bench — following Gullipilli Sowria Raj v. Bandaru Pavani, (2009) 1 SCC 714, and the Division Bench ruling in Jeyakumari v. Stephen — held a Hindu-Christian marriage cannot be solemnised under the Act and cannot be validated by mere registration. The lawful route for such a couple is the Special Marriage Act, 1954 (or solemnisation under the Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872, where it applies).
What else did the court order?
Noting that it had taken sixteen years to undo the registration, and that the register wrongly recorded the plaintiff as Hindu while the respondent admitted no ceremony occurred, the Bench directed that copies of the judgment go to the Inspector General of Registration, Chennai, for circulation to all Marriage Registrars, and to all Family Courts in Tamil Nadu. No costs were awarded.