When a commercial relationship sours, the temptation to file a criminal complaint is real: the process is cheaper than a suit and the pressure it generates is immediate. Courts, however, police that boundary. In Amrit Cements Limited v. Suraj Jha (C.R.R. No. 3705 of 2024, 2026:CHC-AS:1931, decided 16 November 2026), the Calcutta High Court quashed a complaint under Sections 420, 406 and 120B IPC filed by an interior decorator over unpaid final bills, holding that the dispute over work, quality and dues belonged to a civil forum and that no ingredient of cheating or criminal breach of trust was even alleged.
The transaction behind the complaint
The complainant, an interior decorator, was engaged to renovate the head office of the petitioner company in Calcutta against a quotation of about Rs 38.94 lakh. An advance was paid; the relationship broke down; the company engaged another contractor. The decorator raised final bills of roughly Rs 35.4 lakh and Rs 2.9 lakh, alleged they went unpaid, and filed a complaint (CS/55752/2024) before the Metropolitan Magistrate alleging cheating, criminal breach of trust and conspiracy against the company and its officers. The accused moved the High Court under Section 528 BNSS — the successor to Section 482 CrPC — to quash the proceeding.
How the Court dismantled the complaint
The line the judgment draws
What the complaint said
The company dishonestly withheld payment after the work was done — so the directors cheated the contractor and misappropriated his dues, in conspiracy.
What the law requires
Cheating needs dishonest inducement at inception; breach of trust needs entrustment. A fought-over final bill after a terminated engagement shows neither — it shows a contract dispute.
Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta's reasoning places the decision in a well-established line of Supreme Court authority holding that criminal process must not be used to pressure settlement of commercial claims — the complainant's remedy for a genuine debt lies in a civil action, where the disputes of completion and quality can actually be tried.
For businesses on the receiving end of such complaints: a quashing petition should demonstrate, from the complaint itself, the absence of the statutory ingredients — no representation at inception, no entrustment, no specific dishonest act — and frame the dispute in its true civil character, with the contract, bills and correspondence annexed. For creditors, the converse lesson: invest in the civil or arbitral remedy early; a criminal complaint that is quashed costs time, credibility and sometimes costs orders.
Under the BNS, cheating and criminal breach of trust now live in Sections 318 and 316, and the inherent power in Section 528 BNSS. The nomenclature has changed; the boundary between civil and criminal wrongs has not.
Frequently Asked Questions
When does non-payment become cheating?
Only when dishonest intention existed at the inception of the transaction — the payer induced the work or delivery never intending to pay. Intention formed later, or a genuine dispute about what is due, is breach of contract. The Court found no iota of evidence of dishonest intent at the time of the agreement, which was fatal to the Section 420 charge.
Why did Section 406 fail as well?
Criminal breach of trust requires entrustment of property and its dishonest misappropriation. A contractor's claim for payment of his bills involves no entrustment at all — money owed under a contract is a debt, not property entrusted to the payer. With no entrustment alleged, Section 406 could not stand, and the conspiracy charge under Section 120B fell with the substantive offences.
What disputes did the Court say belong to trial — and where?
Whether the renovation work was completed, its quality, and what remains due on the final bills are questions of fact. The Court held these are for a civil forum to decide — by suit or any agreed mechanism — not for a Magistrate conducting a criminal trial under the guise of a cheating case.
Does quashing leave the contractor without remedy?
No. Quashing ends only the criminal case. The contractor's money claim survives untouched and can be pursued civilly — where, if the claim is good, he recovers with interest; the point of the ruling is that the criminal process cannot be used as a recovery agent.