What happens to a pending cheque dishonour complaint when the lender assigns the underlying debt to an asset reconstruction company? In Kishore Avarsekar v. Assets Care and Reconstruction Enterprises Ltd (SLP (Crl.) No. 20619 of 2026; 2026 INSC 1217, reportable, decided 4 November 2026), a Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu dismissed the accused’s challenge to the ARC’s substitution as complainant — while adding a caveat that will shape how these trials are fought: assignment does not, per se, make the ARC the payee or the holder in due course.
The question of survival
Cheque complaints are creatures of the payee: Section 142 of the NI Act requires the complaint to be made by the payee or holder in due course. When a bank assigns a loan book to an ARC midway through a prosecution, accused persons routinely argue that the complaint dies with the assignment — the ARC was never the payee, so it cannot prosecute. The petitioners pressed exactly this, relying on decisions under the Companies Act and the IBC. The Court held those statutes operate in different fields and cannot control the SARFAESI scheme.
“Other proceeding of whatever nature”
The pivot of the judgment is Section 5(4) of the SARFAESI Act. The Court refused to read the residual phrase narrowly:
The caveat that defence counsel will use
The judgment is a win for ARCs at the threshold, but it hands the defence a structured trial strategy. The Court listed what the substituted complainant must establish: that the dishonoured cheque itself travelled with the financial asset under the assignment agreement; that the transfer amounts to an endorsement or assignment sufficient under Sections 8 and 9 of the NI Act; and that every ingredient of Section 138 — presentment, dishonour, notice, non-payment — stands proved. As the Court put it, such questions of fact “must obviously be decided on the basis of evidence led at the trial.”
Practical notes for both sides
For Delhi practitioners, the decision matters daily: a large share of pending Section 138 dockets in the district courts trace back to assigned bank debts, and magistrates now have clear appellate backing both for allowing substitution and for insisting on strict proof thereafter.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the procedural history?
Axis Bank filed a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act over three dishonoured post-dated cheques, then assigned the debt — including the cheques, return memos, demand notice and the right to continue pending complaints — to the ARC. The Metropolitan Magistrate, 28th Court, Esplanade, Mumbai allowed substitution on 5 September 2018; the Sessions Court dismissed the revision on 11 February 2021; the Bombay High Court dismissed the writ petition on 3 August 2026; and the Supreme Court has now dismissed the SLP.
What does Section 5(4) of the SARFAESI Act say?
Where an ARC acquires a financial asset, any suit, appeal or “other proceeding of whatever nature” relating to that asset may be continued by the ARC. The Court held this phrase is not confined, by ejusdem generis, to civil suits and appeals — it covers a criminal complaint under Section 138 relating to the acquired asset. Section 5(5) permits substitution, though with the originator’s consent.
Does substitution mean the ARC automatically wins?
No. The Court held the ARC must be put to strict proof that the dishonoured cheque itself was transferred with the asset, that there was an endorsement or assignment sufficient to make it a holder in due course under Sections 8 and 9 of the NI Act, that the Section 138 ingredients are met, and that it is not improving on the original complainant’s case. These are questions of fact for the trial.
Is a plea like this available to every accused?
All other contentions of the accused were expressly kept open before the trial magistrate. An accused facing a substituted complainant can still contest the validity of the assignment, the holder-in-due-course question and every ingredient of the offence at trial — what the accused cannot do, after this judgment, is defeat the complaint at the threshold merely because the complainant changed.