The criminal revisional jurisdiction exists, among other things, to stop prosecutions that state no offence. In Tanmoy Roy v. State of West Bengal (C.R.R. No. 409 of 2025, 2026:CHC-AS:1932, decided 16 November 2026), the Calcutta High Court quashed a prosecution under Sections 498A and 34 of the IPC where the allegations of torture were bald and unparticularised, the co-accused mother-in-law and sister-in-law had already had their proceedings quashed, and the only concrete grievance against the husband was that he did not answer his wife's phone calls.
The proceeding under challenge
The parties married on 2 March 2017 and have a son. The wife's complaint became Bagnan P.S. Case No. 431 of 2020, alleging cruelty by the husband and his relatives; a charge sheet followed against three accused, and the case was pending as G.R. Case No. 2275 of 2020. The husband — who said he was studying in Haridwar during the relevant period — moved the High Court under Section 482 CrPC read with Article 227 (the jurisdiction now carried by Section 528 BNSS) to quash the proceeding.
The Court's analysis
Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta also disposed of two recurring side-arguments. The Lalita Kumari point — that the FIR was vitiated for want of a preliminary inquiry — failed, because the discretion to hold such an inquiry in matrimonial cases is not a precondition to registration (para 32). And defences touching the parallel Domestic Violence Act case were left to be decided in those proceedings (para 34).
A pattern worth noting
This is the second 498A quashing delivered by the same Bench on the same day — in the companion decision, a prosecution built on an alleged extramarital affair met the same fate. Read together, the orders restate a consistent judicial method: identify the specific acts alleged, test them against the Explanation to Section 498A, and refuse to let adjectives substitute for particulars.
| Allegation type | Survives quashing scrutiny? |
|---|---|
| Dated, specific acts of violence or harassment linked to demands | Yes — matter for trial |
| General words — "torture", "cruelty" — without particulars | No — Bhajan Lal categories (1) and (3) |
| Conduct outside the Explanation (unanswered calls, estrangement) | No — not the statutory offence |
| Allegations already rejected qua co-accused, repeated verbatim | Weakened — abuse of process analysis applies |
For practitioners: where co-accused family members have already been exonerated, obtain those orders and plead them: they frame the surviving prosecution's weakness. For complainants, the same orders are a drafting lesson — a complaint that records specific incidents with dates and context survives; one that relies on conclusory labels may not reach trial at all.
Quashing under the inherent power is confined to the criminal case. The matrimonial relationship, maintenance questions and the pending DV Act proceeding remain to be worked out in their own forums — on evidence, not adjectives.
Frequently Asked Questions
What must a Section 498A complaint actually allege?
Conduct falling within the Explanation to the section: wilful conduct likely to drive the woman to suicide or cause grave injury to life, limb or health (mental or physical), or harassment connected with unlawful demands. Courts insist on particulars — what was done, when, and how — because vague words like "torture" do not themselves constitute the offence.
Why did the earlier quashing orders for the in-laws matter?
The mother-in-law and sister-in-law had already obtained quashing in CRR 1195 of 2022 and CRR 2232 of 2022. While each accused's case is assessed on his or her own role, those orders confirmed the complaint's lack of particulars, and prosecuting the husband alone on the same vague foundation was held to be an abuse of process.
Can a prosecution be challenged because no preliminary inquiry preceded the FIR?
Not usually. The Court rejected the argument based on Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh, holding that an FIR is not bad merely because no preliminary inquiry was held in a matrimonial case — the discretion to hold one does not convert into a condition of validity.
Does quashing the 498A case affect the pending DV Act proceeding?
No. The judgment notes a parallel case under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act and leaves defences and claims there untouched. The DV Act proceeding is civil in nature and continues on its own footing.