Section 498A of the IPC punishes cruelty of a defined kind — conduct likely to drive a woman to suicide or cause grave injury, or harassment linked to unlawful demands. It is not a general penal remedy for marital wrongs. In Mahinder Singh Sekhon v. State of West Bengal (C.R.R. No. 2178 of 2022, 2026:CHC-AS:1930, decided 16 November 2026), the Calcutta High Court quashed a prosecution arising from allegations that the husband had concealed an extramarital relationship, holding that such a relationship, without more, does not amount to cruelty under Section 498A.
The complaint and its background
The wife's written complaint of 19 October 2020 led to Ekbalpore P.S. Case No. 365 of 2020 under Section 498A IPC against the husband, then about 69 years old. The gravamen was that he had concealed an extramarital relationship. The marital history was long and layered: a 1988 decree had declared the wife's earlier marriage void, the parties married in 1992, and by 2018 the wife had herself filed a suit for restitution of conjugal rights under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, alongside allegations concerning property transfers. A charge sheet followed on 31 December 2021, and cognizance was taken in January 2022. The husband sought quashing under Section 482 CrPC.
Why the prosecution could not stand
Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta anchored the statutory point in the Supreme Court's decisions in Pinakin Mahipatray Rawal v. State of Gujarat and Wasim v. State (NCT of Delhi): Section 498A cruelty means conduct likely to drive the woman to suicide or cause grave injury to life, limb or health, or harassment coupled with unlawful demands. Marital infidelity may wound, and it has civil and matrimonial consequences — but the Explanation to Section 498A, not the marriage's moral ledger, defines the crime.
The dividing line
| Conduct | Where it is addressed |
|---|---|
| Extramarital relationship, without statutory cruelty | Divorce, judicial separation, maintenance consequences — civil forums |
| Conduct likely to drive the woman to suicide or cause grave injury | Section 498A IPC / Section 85 BNS — criminal prosecution |
| Harassment for dowry or unlawful demands | Section 498A Explanation (b), Dowry Prohibition Act |
| Domestic violence needing protection or residence orders | Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 |
For accused spouses: where a 498A complaint pleads betrayal but no statutory cruelty — no particulars of acts, no demand, no injury — a quashing petition that maps each allegation against the Explanation to the section, and against the Bhajan Lal categories, can end the prosecution without a trial. The parallel matrimonial record matters too: pending civil suits often explain the complaint's timing and colour.
The decision does not hold that infidelity is beyond the criminal law in every case: where an affair is one strand in a pattern of statutory cruelty, prosecutions survive. What it refuses is the conversion of a broken marriage's bitterness into a criminal case unsupported by the particulars the offence requires. Under the BNS, the same analysis now applies to Section 85, which carries Section 498A forward.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an extramarital affair an offence under Indian law?
Adultery ceased to be a criminal offence when the Supreme Court struck down Section 497 IPC in 2018, and the BNS does not revive it. An affair remains a matrimonial wrong — a ground for divorce, and relevant in maintenance and custody disputes — but it becomes criminal cruelty under Section 498A only where it is accompanied by conduct of the kind the Explanation to that section defines.
What made the allegations in this case omnibus?
The Court found the FIR and the witness statements general and lacking particulars — no dates, times or manner of the alleged cruelty. Specific allegations of abuse attributed to the sons in their police statements did not figure in the mother's own written complaint, which further weakened the prosecution's foundation.
Which precedents did the Court apply?
The petitioner relied on Pinakin Mahipatray Rawal v. State of Gujarat and Wasim v. State (NCT of Delhi), where the Supreme Court held that an extramarital relationship, by itself, is not cruelty of the statutory kind. The quashing itself proceeded on the categories recognised in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal — allegations not constituting an offence, and proceedings amounting to abuse of process.
Does quashing bar the wife's civil and matrimonial remedies?
No. Quashing ends the criminal prosecution. Matrimonial proceedings — such as the pending restitution suit the judgment notes — and civil disputes over property proceed independently, decided on their own standards of proof.