Suppliers who discover the MSME Samadhaan route sometimes treat the Facilitation Council as an all-purpose commercial court: delayed payments, cancelled orders, lost profits, stock bought for a project that never happened — everything goes into the reference. That is a mistake with consequences, because the Council’s jurisdiction under Section 18 of the MSMED Act, 2006 is anchored to one defined thing: the amount due under Section 17. Understanding what fits inside that basket, and what does not, saves suppliers months and keeps awards safe from challenge.
The statutory chain: Sections 15, 16, 17 and 18
The delayed-payment scheme of the MSMED Act is a chain of four links. Section 15 fixes the buyer’s obligation: payment on or before the agreed date, and in no case beyond forty-five days from the day of acceptance or deemed acceptance. Section 16 attaches the sanction: on failure, compound interest with monthly rests at three times the bank rate notified by the Reserve Bank of India, running from the appointed day or the agreed date. Section 17 declares what the buyer is liable to pay — the amount with the interest thereon. Section 18 then opens the forum: any party to a dispute may make a reference to the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council with regard to any amount due under Section 17.
Those last words are the jurisdictional anchor. The Council’s process — conciliation first, and failing settlement, arbitration under Section 18(3) as if under an arbitration agreement, with a ninety-day target in Section 18(5) — exists to quantify and recover the price of what was actually supplied or rendered, plus the statutory interest. It is a recovery engine, not a general commercial tribunal.
Inside and outside the basket
The line is functional, not formal. If the claim answers the question “what remains unpaid for what I supplied?”, it belongs in the reference. If it answers “what did the buyer’s conduct cost my business?”, it is a damages claim for a civil or commercial suit, or for arbitration under the contract’s own clause where one exists.
The buyer’s side of the same line
None of this leaves the buyer defenceless inside the reference. Disputes about whether goods were supplied, whether they conformed to specification, and how much is genuinely due are precisely what the Section 18 process adjudicates; the buyer’s quality and quantity objections operate within it, and counter-claims by the buyer have been held maintainable in the statutory arbitration. What the buyer cannot achieve is escape: Section 24 gives Sections 15 to 23 overriding effect over anything inconsistent in any other law, and a challenge to the eventual award requires the deposit of seventy-five per cent of the awarded amount under Section 19 before it will even be entertained.
Drafting the reference strategically
Plead the supply, not the grievance: anchor every head of claim to identified invoices, delivery challans, acceptance and the Section 15 due dates. The interest computation should be annexed, compounded monthly at three times the notified bank rate.
Strip out damages heads before filing. Claims that do not belong weaken the ones that do, and give the buyer its best argument on a Section 19 challenge.
Run parallel tracks consciously: a Samadhaan reference for the amounts due, and — where real breach losses exist — a separate suit or contractual arbitration for damages, each pleaded consistently with the other.
Preserve the record of acceptance: deemed acceptance after fifteen days without written objection is frequently the decisive fact in these references.
Frequently Asked Questions
What exactly can a supplier claim before the Facilitation Council?
The amount due under Section 17: the principal payable for goods supplied or services rendered that the buyer has not paid within the time allowed by Section 15, together with compound interest under Section 16 at three times the bank rate notified by the Reserve Bank, with monthly rests, running from the appointed day or the agreed date of payment.
Can the Council award damages for a cancelled purchase order?
No. Compensation for breach — lost profits on orders never executed, costs of raw material bought in anticipation, damage to business reputation — is not an “amount due” for goods supplied or services rendered. Those are damages claims, to be pursued in a civil or commercial suit or in arbitration under the contract, not in a Section 18 reference.
Can the buyer raise quality disputes and counter-claims in the reference?
The buyer can certainly contest liability — disputing supply, deficiency or quantum is what the conciliation and arbitration under Section 18 exist to resolve, and counter-claims by the buyer have been held maintainable in that statutory arbitration. What the buyer cannot do is use objections as a reason to bypass the forum: Section 24 gives the Act overriding effect.
What happens if an award includes claims outside Section 17?
It becomes vulnerable. A buyer challenging the award — after the 75 per cent pre-deposit that Section 19 demands — will argue that the Council travelled beyond its statutory jurisdiction. A supplier who keeps the reference within the statutory basket, and routes the rest of its claims to the right forum, protects both.