Arbitration stands or falls on the neutrality of the person deciding it. The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 — reshaped on this point by the 2015 amendments — approaches the problem from both ends: it obliges every prospective arbitrator to disclose circumstances bearing on independence, and it gives parties a structured, time-bound mechanism to challenge an appointment that disclosure or discovery puts in doubt. Knowing which of the two schedules a relationship falls under, and which of the two procedural routes applies, decides most challenges before they are argued.
Disclosure first: Section 12(1) and the Sixth Schedule form
Every person approached for appointment as arbitrator must disclose in writing, in the Sixth Schedule format, two kinds of circumstances: relationships — direct or indirect, past or present, financial, business, professional or of any other kind — with the parties, their counsel or the subject-matter of the dispute, which are likely to give rise to justifiable doubts as to independence or impartiality; and anything likely to affect the ability to devote sufficient time to the arbitration and finish it expeditiously. The Fifth Schedule supplies the working list of what counts for the first category. Disclosure is not a one-time event: the duty continues through the proceedings.
Two schedules, two consequences
The grounds of challenge themselves are two, and only two: circumstances giving rise to justifiable doubts about independence or impartiality, or the arbitrator’s lack of qualifications the parties agreed upon. A party who appointed, or participated in appointing, the arbitrator may challenge only for reasons it became aware of after the appointment was made — Section 12(4) shuts the door on tactical second thoughts.
The Section 13 procedure and its fifteen-day clock
This architecture is deliberate. It denies a disgruntled party the power to stall the reference by manufacturing bias objections, while ensuring that a genuine objection, raised in time and rejected, loses nothing: the setting-aside court examines it with the award. Where an award is set aside on such a challenge, the court may also decide whether the arbitrator is entitled to fees.
The court route: Section 14 for de jure inability
Seventh Schedule ineligibility is not merely a ground of challenge — it is a de jure inability to act, terminating the mandate by operation of law. Section 14 permits a party to apply to the court to decide the controversy over termination, which means an ineligible appointment can be dislodged without waiting years for an award. The same route serves where an arbitrator becomes de facto unable to act or fails to proceed without undue delay. A substitute arbitrator is then appointed under Section 15 by the rules that governed the original appointment.
Practical counsel
Read the disclosure the day it arrives, and diarise the fifteen days. The commonest fatality in challenge practice is the calendar, not the merits.
Classify before you challenge: a Seventh Schedule relationship supports a Section 14 court application; a Fifth Schedule circumstance belongs before the tribunal under Section 13. Choosing the wrong door wastes months.
Mind Section 12(5) waivers: only an express written agreement made after disputes arise cures ineligibility. Clauses signed at the contract stage cannot.
Record everything: if the challenge fails and the matter proceeds, the Section 34 court will see only what the record preserves.
Frequently Asked Questions
What must an arbitrator disclose before accepting appointment?
Section 12(1) requires written disclosure, in the form prescribed by the Sixth Schedule, of any direct or indirect relationship with the parties, counsel or subject-matter — financial, business, professional or otherwise — likely to give rise to justifiable doubts about independence or impartiality, with the Fifth Schedule serving as the guide, and of any circumstances affecting the ability to devote sufficient time to complete the arbitration expeditiously.
What is the difference between the Fifth and Seventh Schedules?
The Fifth Schedule lists circumstances that may give rise to justifiable doubts — they found a challenge, which the tribunal assesses. The Seventh Schedule lists graver relationships that make a person ineligible to act as arbitrator at all under Section 12(5). Seventh Schedule ineligibility operates by law and can be waived only by an express agreement in writing made after the disputes have arisen.
How quickly must a challenge be raised?
Unless the parties have agreed a procedure, Section 13 requires a written statement of reasons to the tribunal within fifteen days of learning of the tribunal’s constitution or of the circumstances founding the challenge, whichever is later. Sitting on known circumstances and challenging only after an unfavourable procedural ruling is the classic route to rejection.
What happens if the tribunal rejects the challenge?
The tribunal continues the proceedings and makes its award. The challenging party’s remedy is preserved, not lost: it may apply to set aside the award under Section 34 on the same grounds. Where the complaint is Seventh Schedule ineligibility, the mandate terminates by law, and the controversy can be taken to court under Section 14 without waiting for the award.