Second marriages are no longer exceptional, and with them come questions the drafters of our maintenance provisions answered only partially: must a man maintain his wife’s children from her earlier marriage? Can a stepmother, widowed and without her own children, claim from her stepson? The answers lie scattered across Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 and the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 — and they do not all point the same way.
Why the statutes diverge
Maintenance law in India is a layered construction: a secular, summary remedy (Section 125 CrPC, now Section 144 BNSS) designed to prevent destitution; personal-law codes such as HAMA that distribute family obligations among Hindus; and a welfare statute for the elderly that deliberately widens every definition. Each was drafted with a paradigm family in mind, and the step-relationship tests the edges of all three. The result is that the same household can yield different answers depending on which door is knocked.
| Relationship | Section 144 BNSS | HAMA 1956 | Senior Citizens Act 2007 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stepchild v. stepparent | Not within “his or her child”; claim lies against natural parent | No direct obligation inter vivos; estate route via Sections 21-22 possible | Not applicable (claimant must be a parent/senior) |
| Childless stepmother v. stepson | Arguable as “mother”; strongest when widowed and childless | Yes — explanation to Section 20 includes childless stepmother | Yes — “parent” includes step-parent |
| Stepmother with own children | Weak; expected to claim from own sons/husband | Outside the Section 20 explanation | Yes, if a senior citizen; Tribunal apportions among children |
The child’s side: practical routes in blended families
Where a minor lives with the mother and stepfather, and the natural father is alive, the clean claim is the child’s petition under Section 144 BNSS against the natural father — his remarriage, or the mother’s, does not dilute the obligation. Where the natural father has died, counsel should look to the estate: HAMA Section 22 makes heirs liable to maintain the deceased’s dependants from inherited property, and a minor child is a dependant of the first order. The DV Act adds a further layer where the mother is an aggrieved person: monetary relief under Section 20 of that Act expressly includes maintenance “for the aggrieved person as well as her children”, a phrase wide enough to fund the actual household in which the children live.
The stepmother’s side: building the claim
Points both sides should watch
The step-relationship must be real in substance: courts examine whether the claimant was actually part of the respondent’s family fold, not merely connected by a late remarriage.
Multiple obligors can coexist — natural children, stepchildren, a living spouse. Apportionment arguments should be raised at the first hearing, not in execution.
Orders under one statute do not bar another forum, but amounts are adjusted; disclose every pending or decided claim to avoid the double-recovery objection.
For conduct after 1 July 2024, cite the BNSS provision (Section 144) rather than Section 125 CrPC, while noting that the substantive principles carry over.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Section 144 BNSS cover stepchildren claiming from a stepfather?
The provision obliges a person to maintain “his or her legitimate or illegitimate minor child”. A stepchild is, in strict terms, the child of the spouse, not of the stepparent, so the provision does not in terms reach the step-relationship. The child’s primary claim lies against the natural parent. The practical pressure point arises where the natural father is dead or untraceable — there, the mother’s own claim as wife, which includes amounts for children in her care through the DV Act and matrimonial statutes, carries the burden.
Can a stepmother claim maintenance as a “mother” under Section 144 BNSS?
The text says “father or mother, unable to maintain himself or herself”. Courts have grappled with whether a stepmother fits the word “mother”; the position that has gained acceptance is cautious — a childless stepmother who is widowed, or whose husband is incapable of maintaining her, stands on the strongest footing, because she then has no natural son to look to and the stepson is in substance her family. A stepmother with her own capable children or a living, earning husband is expected to look to them first.
What does Hindu law provide?
HAMA is more explicit. The explanation to Section 20 extends “parent” to include a childless stepmother, giving her a statutory claim against stepchildren who are Hindus. Separately, Section 22 obliges heirs of a deceased Hindu to maintain his dependants out of the estate they inherit — and Section 21 lists the widow, minor children and certain other relatives as dependants, which can pick up members of a blended family where the estate route applies.
Does the Senior Citizens Act, 2007 change the picture for elderly stepparents?
Substantially. “Children” under Section 2(a) includes sons, daughters, grandsons and granddaughters (excluding minors), and “parent” under Section 2(d) expressly includes a step-parent, whether or not a senior citizen. An elderly stepmother or stepfather can therefore invoke the Tribunal’s summary machinery against stepchildren — often the most efficient remedy available.