The most common obstacle a special leave petition faces is not limitation or court fees — it is the sentence, repeated in thousands of orders, that the Supreme Court does not ordinarily interfere with concurrent findings of fact. When the trial court and the first appellate court (or the High Court in second appeal or revision) have reached the same factual conclusions, Article 136 treats those conclusions as settled. The rule is one of practice and self-restraint rather than a statutory bar, which is why it has exceptions; but the exceptions are narrow, defined, and must be demonstrated from the record rather than asserted.
The rule and its rationale
Article 136 confers a discretionary power to grant special leave against any order of any court or tribunal. From the beginning, the Supreme Court has administered that power with self-imposed limits, of which the concurrent-findings rule is the most consequential in everyday practice. Its logic is institutional: facts are found in the forums designed for fact-finding, with oral evidence, cross-examination and full records; the Supreme Court’s function is to correct errors of law, resolve conflicts of principle, and intervene where injustice is manifest. Concurrence between two courts is treated as strong assurance that the factual foundation is sound — a presumption, not an immunity.
Where the door opens
Drafting for the first hearing
A concurrent-findings SLP is usually decided in minutes at the admission stage, so the petition must put the infirmity on the surface. Three disciplines help. First, isolate: challenge the one or two findings that actually decide the case, not every adverse observation. Second, anchor: every assertion of perversity should carry a pinpoint reference to the deposition or exhibit, with the relevant passage extracted in the petition or its annexures — the Bench will not excavate the record. Third, connect: show that correcting the finding changes the outcome. A petition that establishes a flaw in a peripheral finding earns a dismissal with the observation that the result stands regardless.
The respondent’s playbook
For respondents defending concurrent findings, the strategy is the mirror image: open with the concurrence itself; demonstrate that the so-called perversity is a request for reappreciation; and show that each piece of “ignored” evidence was either considered or immaterial. A caveat filed in anticipation ensures the respondent is heard before any interim order — particularly important where the decree under challenge is executable, since an ex parte stay can freeze the fruits of a decade of litigation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does the Supreme Court defer to concurrent findings?
Because Article 136 creates a residual, discretionary jurisdiction for exceptional situations, not a general third appeal. The trial court saw the witnesses; the appellate court re-examined the full record. Where both reach the same conclusion, a further factual review would convert the Supreme Court into a court of ordinary appeal for the entire country — something its role and docket cannot accommodate.
What are the recognised exceptions?
Findings that are perverse — conclusions no reasonable court could reach on the evidence; findings based on no evidence at all; findings arrived at by ignoring vital, admissible evidence or by relying on inadmissible material; misconstruction of a document that goes to the root of the case; and findings vitiated by a wrong legal standard — for example, placing the burden of proof on the wrong party.
Is the rule the same in civil and criminal matters?
The principle of restraint is common, but in criminal appeals the Court is historically more willing to re-open the record where a conviction rests on evidence it finds unreliable, because personal liberty is at stake. Even there, the petition must show a specific infirmity — contradictions on material particulars, impossible testimony, ignored exculpatory material — not merely invite reappreciation.
How should an SLP plead the exception?
Identify the specific finding challenged; quote the evidence said to make it perverse or unsupported, with record references; and show that the error is material — that the result could not stand without the flawed finding. Petitions that argue the evidence “ought to have been weighed differently” concede the case away, because weighing differently is exactly what Article 136 refuses to do.