Defending a suit costs money, and a defendant who wins may discover that the costs decree is worthless because the plaintiff has nothing in India to execute against. The Code of Civil Procedure anticipated the problem more than a century ago: Order XXV empowers the court to order the plaintiff to give security for the defendant’s costs, and to dismiss the suit if the security is not furnished. In an era of cross-border commerce and forum-shopping plaintiffs, the provision deserves more use than it gets.
The provision and its logic
Order XXV Rule 1(1) states the power: at any stage of a suit, the court may, either of its own motion or on the application of any defendant, order the plaintiff, for reasons to be recorded, to give within the time fixed by it security for the payment of all costs incurred and likely to be incurred by any defendant. The proviso then identifies the paradigm case — it directs that such an order shall be made in all cases in which it appears to the court that a sole plaintiff is, or all the plaintiffs are, residing out of India and do not possess sufficient immovable property within India other than the property in suit.
The logic is symmetry. The defendant has no choice about being sued; the least the process can do is ensure that a successful defence is not a pyrrhic one. Security for costs does not prejudge the claim — it prices the plaintiff’s access to the defendant’s time at the value of the costs the plaintiff would owe on losing.
How the application works
Where it earns its keep today
Strategic cautions
Three cautions keep the tool sharp. First, do not over-ask: an inflated security demand reads as an attempt to stifle the suit and invites rejection of the application altogether. Second, remember the court’s countervailing concern for access to justice; the application should rest on the plaintiff’s asset geography and conduct, never on mere poverty. Third, the order protects costs, not the claim — a defendant who wins a security order has secured its expenses, and nothing more; the merits battle remains to be fought and won on its own terms.
Frequently Asked Questions
When can security for costs be ordered?
Order XXV Rule 1 gives the court a general discretion, at any stage, to order a plaintiff to give security for the defendant’s costs. The rule makes the order practically expected in one situation: where the sole plaintiff — or every plaintiff — resides outside India and does not possess sufficient immovable property in India other than the suit property.
What happens if the plaintiff does not furnish security?
Order XXV Rule 2 provides the sanction: the court shall dismiss the suit unless the plaintiff is permitted to withdraw. A plaintiff whose suit is dismissed for default of security may apply to have the dismissal set aside by showing sufficient cause, broadly on the pattern of restoration applications elsewhere in the Code.
Does the provision apply in commercial suits?
Yes. The Commercial Courts Act, 2015 modifies the CPC for commercial disputes in specified respects, and Order XXV is not among the provisions displaced. Combined with the costs-follow-the-event philosophy of the commercial courts regime, a security order can be a meaningful shield for defendants facing claims from shell entities or foreign plaintiffs with no Indian assets.
Can security be demanded from every impecunious plaintiff?
No. Poverty alone is not a ground — access to justice would otherwise be priced out. The discretionary jurisdiction is exercised on case-specific indicators: foreign residence without Indian assets, a plaintiff suing as a front, or conduct suggesting the suit is vexatious. Courts balance the defendant’s protection against the plaintiff’s right to be heard.