In Aditya Birla Capital Ltd. v. VSG Motors (O.M.P.(I) (COMM.) 536/2026, decided on 20 November 2026), the Delhi High Court dismissed a Section 9 petition by a lender seeking sweeping interim measures — asset disclosure, attachment, freezing of bank accounts and a bank guarantee — over a defaulted facility of about Rs 5.29 crore. The lender already held a mortgage over property in Tiruppur and had issued a demand notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act. Justice Om Prakash Shukla held that with a subsisting security interest and the statutory enforcement route already engaged, no case for additional interim protection was made out.
The facility and the default
The respondents had taken financial facilities, restructured under a sanction letter of September 2021 totalling about Rs 5.65 crore, secured by a mortgage over property at Tiruppur, Tamil Nadu. The account slipped into NPA classification in September 2026; a loan recall notice followed in October, with the outstanding claimed at Rs 5.29 crore; and the lender issued a demand notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002. Alongside that statutory track, the lender moved the High Court under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, seeking ex parte interim measures: disclosure of assets, attachment, freezing of bank accounts, a bank guarantee for the outstanding, and restraint on dealing with the mortgaged property.
The Court’s reasoning
Concurrent pursuit of SARFAESI and arbitration remains permissible under M.D. Frozen Foods, but permissibility of parallel remedies is not an entitlement to parallel protections. With a subsisting security interest, an engaged statutory route, and the comfort that any third-party rights created over the mortgaged property would remain subject to the mortgage, the petition was dismissed — expressly without prejudice to other remedies.
What this means for NBFC and lender practice
Section 9 petitions have become a standard first strike in lender recoveries, often seeking the full menu of protective orders. This decision, following the Division Bench’s lead, marks the limit: the interim jurisdiction protects the eventual award from being rendered illusory, and where the lender already holds registered security adequate to the claim, the award is not in jeopardy. Lenders who genuinely need Section 9 orders should come prepared to show a protection gap — valuations indicating erosion of the security, evidence of dissipation of unsecured assets, or obstacles to statutory enforcement. Borrowers resisting such petitions should put the lender’s security package and its SARFAESI steps front and centre, because the overlap is now a recognised ground of refusal.
The borrower’s side of the ledger
The dismissal is not an escape for borrowers. The mortgage continues to bind the property and anyone who takes it; the SARFAESI timeline continues to run from the Section 13(2) notice, with possession measures under Section 13(4) and the Section 17 remedy before the DRT ahead; and the arbitration itself proceeds to an award that can be enforced as a decree. What the judgment polices is the forum and the sequence, not the debt.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a lender pursue SARFAESI and arbitration at the same time?
Yes. The Supreme Court held in M.D. Frozen Foods Exports v. Hero Fincorp, (2017) 16 SCC 741, that SARFAESI enforcement and arbitration are cumulative, not inconsistent, remedies. What this judgment adds is that running both does not entitle the lender to interim court protection on top of its existing security as a matter of course.
Why was interim relief refused here?
Three strands: a Division Bench in Axis Finance Ltd. v. Rishab Mago had upheld refusal of Section 9 relief where mortgage security subsisted; no material showed the existing security inadequate; and the petitioner declined to undertake not to proceed further under SARFAESI — it wanted the statutory remedy and court protection simultaneously.
Does the dismissal leave the borrower free to alienate assets?
Not meaningfully. The Court noted that any third-party rights created over the mortgaged property would remain subject to the petitioner’s rights as mortgagee — a registered mortgage binds transferees. The dismissal also expressly left other remedies open.
When does Section 9 relief remain available to secured lenders?
Where the lender shows the security is inadequate or at genuine risk — for example, perishable or depreciating hypothecated assets being dissipated — or where enforcement under the statute is unavailable or obstructed. The touchstone remains the ordinary principles for interim measures, applied to the lender’s actual exposure.