The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 is often described as a civil statute with a criminal spine. The description is accurate, and Section 31 is the spine: while residence orders, monetary relief and compensation operate as civil remedies, the breach of a protection order — or of an interim protection order — is itself a criminal offence, punishable with imprisonment of up to one year, a fine of up to twenty thousand rupees, or both. For an aggrieved woman, Section 31 is what converts a paper order into enforceable protection; for a respondent, it is the provision that makes casual non-compliance genuinely dangerous.
Where Section 31 sits in the scheme
A protection order under Section 18 of the DV Act prohibits the respondent from committing acts of domestic violence, aiding or abetting them, entering the aggrieved person’s workplace or school, attempting to communicate with her, alienating joint assets or operating joint lockers, and causing violence to her relatives. The order may be interim under Section 23 or final after inquiry. Until breach, the proceedings carry no criminal consequence for the respondent. Section 31 changes that on the first violation: the breach is a fresh, self-contained offence, independent of whether the original conduct complained of was ever prosecuted.
The mechanics of a breach prosecution
What each side should understand
| For the aggrieved person | For the respondent |
|---|---|
| Precision in the protection order pays off later: an order that names the prohibited acts, places and modes of contact makes breach easy to establish. | Read the order as a strict boundary. “Innocent” contact — messages seeking reconciliation, appearing at the school, calls through relatives — can constitute breach if the order prohibits communication. |
| Document every incident immediately; delay invites the defence of fabrication. | If circumstances genuinely require interaction (shared children, joint property), seek modification of the order under Section 25 rather than self-help. |
| Press for Section 31(3) consolidation where fresh cruelty accompanies the breach. | Remember the offence is non-bailable; an arrest is a realistic consequence, and anticipatory protection may need to be considered on proper advice. |
Breach of other orders: the enforcement map
Section 31 is confined to protection orders. Monetary relief that goes unpaid is enforced under Section 20(6) — including by directing an employer or debtor of the respondent to pay the aggrieved person directly — and through the mechanism the Magistrate adopts for maintenance enforcement. Residence orders are implemented with the assistance of Protection Officers and, where the order so directs, the police under Section 19(5) and (7). A respondent’s conduct will often engage more than one of these tracks at once, and the choice of enforcement route is a matter of strategy: the criminal route under Section 31 carries the greatest deterrent force, while the monetary mechanisms recover arrears more directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which orders does Section 31 cover?
The breach of a protection order under Section 18, or of an interim protection order, by the respondent. Monetary orders and residence orders are enforced through their own mechanisms, but conduct that also violates the protection order — entering the workplace, attempting contact, committing further violence — falls within Section 31.
Is the Section 31 offence bailable?
No. Section 32(1) makes the offence cognizable and non-bailable. The police can register and investigate without a magistrate’s order, and release is a matter for the court’s discretion rather than of right. This is a significant escalation from the underlying DV proceedings, which involve no arrest at all.
What is the standard of proof?
The breach must be proved like any offence, but Section 32(2) provides that the court may conclude that the offence has been committed upon the sole testimony of the aggrieved person. Corroboration strengthens the case — call records, photographs, witness statements, police complaints contemporaneous with the breach — but its absence is not fatal in law.
Which court tries the breach?
Under Section 31(2), as far as practicable, the Magistrate who passed the order that was breached. Section 31(3) goes further: while framing charges, the Magistrate may also frame charges for offences under Section 498A IPC (now Sections 85 and 86 of the BNS) or the Dowry Prohibition Act if the facts disclose them.