When a marriage breaks down amid allegations of domestic violence, the most urgent question is often not maintenance or the house — it is who keeps the children this month, and whether the other parent may see them. Full-dress custody litigation under the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 or Section 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 answers that question slowly. Section 21 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 answers it quickly: at any stage of the hearing of a DV application, the Magistrate may grant temporary custody of any child or children to the aggrieved person or to a person applying on her behalf, and may specify the arrangements for the respondent’s visits — or refuse visits altogether where they may harm the child.
What the section says, and what it assumes
Section 21 opens with a non-obstante clause — “notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force” — and then confers the power: at any stage of the hearing of an application for a protection order or any other relief under the Act, the Magistrate may grant temporary custody of any child or children to the aggrieved person, and may, if necessary, make arrangements for visit of such child or children by the respondent. The proviso permits outright refusal of visits where they may harm the child’s interests. Three design features follow. The remedy is interlocutory, available “at any stage” and without a separate suit. It is asymmetric: custody can be granted to the aggrieved person, with the respondent’s position addressed through visitation. And it is welfare-driven: the proviso’s test is the child’s interest, not the parents’ equities.
How a Section 21 application is actually fought
Section 21 beside the other custody forums
| Forum | Nature | Time horizon |
|---|---|---|
| Section 21, DV Act (Magistrate) | Temporary custody and visitation during DV proceedings | Immediate; interim by design |
| Section 26, HMA (Family Court) | Interim and final orders about children in matrimonial proceedings | Tied to the matrimonial case |
| Guardians & Wards Act, 1890 (Family Court) | Full guardianship and custody adjudication | The long-term determination |
The practical significance of Section 21 is speed and venue. A woman who has left the matrimonial home with the children and filed a DV application does not need to open a second front immediately; the Magistrate already seized of her case can stabilise the children’s position. Conversely, a respondent facing a one-sided interim arrangement should engage with the DV proceedings on the welfare question — and, where the long-term stakes justify it, institute guardianship proceedings where both parents stand on an equal statutory footing.
Common errors on both sides
Aggrieved persons sometimes treat Section 21 orders as permanent victories and resist all visitation reflexively; courts respond poorly to the weaponising of children, and an unjustified refusal of contact can colour the eventual guardianship inquiry. Respondents, for their part, sometimes bypass the order — collecting children from school, extending visits unilaterally. That conduct invites modification of the arrangement against them and, where a protection order also exists, can amount to its breach, which Section 31 makes a criminal offence. The safe course on both sides is the same: comply, document, and seek modification through the court.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a Section 21 order a final custody decision?
No. The section is expressly about temporary custody, operating during the DV proceedings. Permanent custody and guardianship are decided by the Family Court under the Guardians and Wards Act or the applicable matrimonial statute, where the welfare inquiry is fuller. A Section 21 order holds the position in the meantime, though the status quo it creates often influences later proceedings in practice.
Can the Magistrate refuse the father visitation entirely?
Yes, but only on a specific footing: the proviso to Section 21 permits the Magistrate to refuse visits if of the opinion that any visit of the respondent may be harmful to the interests of the child. Allegations must therefore be directed to the child’s welfare — exposure to violence, abduction risk, substance abuse — rather than to the spousal dispute alone.
Who can seek custody under Section 21?
The aggrieved person, or any person applying on her behalf. The respondent cannot use Section 21 to seek custody for himself; his remedies lie in the guardianship forum. He can, however, seek defined visitation arrangements within the DV proceedings.
Does a Section 21 order bar the Family Court?
No. The DV Act is in addition to, not in derogation of, other laws (Section 36). A Guardians and Wards petition can proceed in parallel, and the Family Court’s eventual order on custody will govern. Courts expect parties to disclose all parallel proceedings, and inconsistent orders are avoided by candour, not concealment.