In Janvee Contracts Pvt. Ltd. v. Ahluwalia Contracts (India) Ltd. (ARB.P. 1811/2026, decided on 19 November 2026), the Delhi High Court dismissed a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, holding that the dispute-resolution clause in a work order — providing that disputes would be “resolved amicably in consultation with Chairman-ACIL” — was not an arbitration agreement under Section 7. The judgment of Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma is a close textual analysis of what separates genuine arbitration clauses from internal escalation mechanisms dressed in arbitral vocabulary.
The dispute
The respondent had issued a work order of May 2021 for concrete batching, mixing, transport and pumping at a medical college project in Hamirpur, valued at about Rs 1.99 crore. The petitioner claimed Rs 19.30 lakh — unpaid dues including a security deposit — with interest, and invoked arbitration by a Section 21 notice in July 2025. The respondent denied the claims and, more fundamentally, denied that any arbitration agreement existed. Everything turned on two clauses of the work order’s Annexure III: Clause 18, under which disputes were to be “resolved amicably in consultation with Chairman-ACIL”, and Clause 19, which conferred exclusive jurisdiction on the courts at Delhi.
The anatomy of a non-arbitration clause
The Court applied Jagdish Chander v. Ramesh Chander, (2007) 5 SCC 719, and Mahanadi Coalfields, (2022) 20 SCC 636, and distinguished the older line of cases — Rukmanibai Gupta and others — where clauses referred disputes to a named authority for decision. It also reaffirmed that at the Section 11 stage the court’s examination is confined to the prima facie existence of an arbitration agreement; but that limited examination cannot manufacture an agreement where the text contains none.
Drafting lessons
Disputes over whether a clause is an arbitration agreement are among the most avoidable in commercial practice. A clause intended to be arbitral should say so in operative words: disputes shall be referred to arbitration; the tribunal’s composition and appointment mechanism; the seat; and the governing rules. Conversely, businesses that intend only an escalation ladder — project manager, then senior management, then litigation — should avoid the word “arbitration” in headings altogether, because it invites precisely this litigation. Where a counterparty’s standard form contains a consultation-style clause, the time to negotiate a real arbitration clause is before signature; after disputes arise, as this case shows, the court will enforce the bargain as written.
The procedural footnote
The petitioner had also been through a failed pre-institution mediation on a different project between the same parties — a reminder that under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, a commercial suit (the petitioner’s remaining route) not contemplating urgent interim relief must be preceded by mediation. The dismissal was with liberty to pursue remedies in accordance with law, and the Court expressed no opinion on the merits of the money claims.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a clause an arbitration agreement?
Section 7 requires an agreement to submit disputes to adjudication by a private tribunal whose decision binds the parties. The settled attributes — drawn from Jagdish Chander v. Ramesh Chander, (2007) 5 SCC 719 — include a reference of disputes for decision, an adjudicatory (not merely consultative) process, and an intention that the outcome bind both sides.
Why did this clause fail the test?
It provided for disputes to be “resolved amicably in consultation with” the Chairman of one party. Consultation is a consensual process, not adjudication; there was no mechanism for submitting claims and defences; the consulted person was the respondent’s own Chairman, indicating an internal mechanism; and the next clause gave Delhi courts exclusive jurisdiction — consistent with litigation, not arbitration.
Does the word “final and binding” or a clause heading change matters?
No. The Court held that finality language cannot be read in isolation, and that a heading such as “Arbitration and Resolution of Dispute” does not control the substance of the clause. What matters is whether the text actually constitutes an adjudicatory reference.
What remains for a party whose clause fails Section 7?
The ordinary remedies: a civil or commercial suit (subject to pre-institution mediation under the Commercial Courts Act where applicable), or negotiation. The Court dismissed the petition with liberty to pursue remedies available in law, expressing no view on the merits of the claims.