Some prosecutions live in ledgers, agreements and bank statements. Once those documents are seized or otherwise secured, the investigative case for arresting the accused thins dramatically — a point the statutory scheme itself recognises when the police choose a notice of appearance over arrest. The Calcutta High Court’s order of 9 November 2026 in Sukumar Adhikari @ Adhikary (C.R.M.(A) 3904 of 2026) brings these threads together in a short, instructive grant of pre-arrest bail.
The application
The petitioner applied under Section 438 CrPC — corresponding to Section 482 BNSS — for anticipatory bail in Taherpur P.S. Case No. 573 of 2026, registered on 7 October 2026 under Sections 316(5), 318(4), 336(3), 61(2) and 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. His counsel’s submissions, as the order records them, were practical: the offences are triable by a Magistrate, a notice under Section 35(3) of the BNSS had been served, the petitioner would cooperate, and custodial interrogation was unnecessary.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee noted two features of the record: the case rests on documentary evidence, and the police had themselves proceeded by Section 35(3) notice. Reading those with the case diary, the Court granted anticipatory bail on conditions.
The order
The Section 35 signal
The BNSS carries forward, in Section 35, the discipline the Supreme Court has long demanded of arrest powers: for offences of moderate gravity, arrest is the exception, and a notice of appearance the norm, unless the officer records why custody is genuinely necessary. When the police have already elected the notice route, an anticipatory bail court is entitled to treat that election as the investigation’s own assessment that detention is not required. The grant of pre-arrest protection in such a case does not second-guess the police; it holds them to their own stated position, while adding judicially enforceable conditions — fortnightly attendance, non-interference — that protect the investigation better than an arrest followed by routine bail would.
Documentary cases: a defence and prosecution checklist
For the defence: establish on affidavit that the relevant records are already with the investigating agency or stand produced, and offer a concrete cooperation schedule — specific dates, not adjectives.
Annex the Section 35(3) notice and proof of compliance. An applicant who appeared on every notice argues from conduct, not promises.
For complainants: if custody is genuinely needed — undisclosed accounts, absconding co-conspirators, continuing diversion of funds — put that material before the court; generalities about the gravity of economic offences will not displace a documentary record.
For both sides: remember that breach of conditions has teeth. Non-appearance before the investigating officer permits the prosecution to seek harsher process, and cancellation applications on proven breach are routinely allowed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Section 35(3) BNSS notice?
Where arrest is not required under Section 35(1), the officer issues a notice directing the person to appear and cooperate. It is the successor to the Section 41A CrPC notice. A person who complies ordinarily cannot be arrested for that offence unless the officer records reasons — so service of such a notice is itself a signal that the police did not consider custody necessary.
Which offences were alleged?
The case — Taherpur P.S. Case No. 573 of 2026 dated 7 October 2026 — invoked Sections 316(5), 318(4), 336(3), 61(2) and 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023: criminal breach of trust, cheating, forgery, conspiracy and common intention, as the order lists them.
Why does the documentary nature of a case favour bail?
Because the evidence is already fixed. Documents seized or produced cannot be intimidated or made to forget; the twin risks that justify custody — tampering and witness interference — are at their lowest, and interrogation can proceed with the accused appearing on notice.
What conditions were imposed?
In the event of arrest, release on a bond of Rs. 20,000 with two sureties of like amount, one local; cooperation with the investigation, including meeting the investigating officer once a fortnight until the chargesheet is filed; and no threatening of witnesses or tampering with evidence.